Comments Thread For: Garcia: Maidana Earned Mayweather With Broner Win

[shenmue]

Broner beat weak ass Paulie by a round hell no he did not earn the fight by beating him

True, losing 2 LWW title fights, then beating LW Carlos Molina (who?, i don't know either) then beating Diaz at CW while getting dropped and battered is better than Maidana beating Karras, Lopez and Broner at WW.

Yep Khan has done more for sure.

[buckfangs]

you guys really think Maidana has improved? he's just fought three guys that stood in front of him, its just careful match making he looks the same to me with the exception of his attempted jabs that he abandons

[A-Wolf]

you guys really think Maidana has improved? he's just fought three guys that stood in front of him, its just careful match making he looks the same to me with the exception of his attempted jabs that he abandons

This one can see.

[buckfangs]

True, losing 2 LWW title fights, then beating LW Carlos Molina (who?, i don't know either) then beating Diaz at CW while getting dropped and battered is better than Maidana beating Karras, Lopez and Broner at WW.

Yep Khan has done more for sure.

He lost to Garcia and lost a close decision to Peterson who are far superior to any of those guys don't forget Lopez was blown up, and just ko'ed and what has Lopez done in his career to be considered a notch in his belt anyway?, i thought the Karass fight was stopped too early and Karass isn't even a title contender and i already covered Broner

[shenmue]

you guys really think Maidana has improved? he's just fought three guys that stood in front of him, its just careful match making he looks the same to me with the exception of his attempted jabs that he abandons

He is less predictable now, much more variety to his offense. If you can't see that then its not my problem.

[shenmue]

He lost to Garcia and lost a close decision to Peterson who are far superior to any of those guys don't forget Lopez was blown up, and just ko'ed and what has Lopez done in his career to be considered a notch in his belt anyway?, i thought the Karass fight was stopped too early and Karass isn't even a title contender and i already covered Broner

Still better than what Khan has done in his last 4 fights. Khan has no wins at WW (Karras and Lopez are hard fights for Khan BTW) the Khan fight is a joke.

[Jack Napier]

wouldn't mind seeing Maidana fight Floyd, but he has no chance
much prefer Maidana-Thurman, that would be great
if Garcia wants to try WW, he and Maidana can be a good fight
whatever happened to Guerrero? he took his check and went home
hell, anybody at WW is a better fight than for him than Floyd
if he wants money, go for it, but no way Maidana gets shut out

[punchr]

Out of the two I think a fight with maidana would be more entertaining Floyd would pick khan away all night styles make fights and the more competitive fight for Floyd would be maidana's style Floyd struggled early on with fighters like hatton and then joe Cortez wouldn't let hatton fight his fight and then well we all know what happened not saying hatton would've won in the end but I think maidana might give Floyd some problems he's tough and hits pretty damn hard and really isn't that slow I think it would be a good fight.

Thank you. I knew I wasn't the only one who saw this.

[punchr]

He is less predictable now, much more variety to his offense. If you can't see that then its not my problem.

So much this. That's two people so far who recognize Maidana's skills.

[shenmue]

Ignore this, wrong post.