Does Khan's win over Maidana really even count?

[!! Shawn]

And how did he knock Khan out??he didn't even knock him down...Maidiana was the one on his ass in that fight

Larry, you should be collecting pay checks from Floyd.

[Dean_Razorback]

So why didn't Maidana KO Khan if it's that simple?

well, khan was fighting maidana, but maidana was fighting khan AND joe cortez. even after the fight maida said that at some point he thought tha cortez was gonna start punching him too.

khan never gave maidana a rematch that he really deserves because he knew he wasn't gonna get lucky again.

broner kos khan inside 6.

amir should have taken the chance against devon, maybe he could've won a title and then no one would be arguing about a potential fight against mayweather but he was too afraid of getting KTFO again and losing the opportunity of a huge paycheck.

[Roy Jones Jnr]

it does count on the record of both (as a win and as a lost) but it doesn't count as a way to justify why Khan't is getting the mayweather fight over maidana right now. current Maidana sends current Khan't into retirement

No it doesn't Deano, no it doesn't.

Only our cards matter pal, and on our cards it's a sure fire L for Khan't(this was pure hilarity and ingenuity as per from you Dean).

Tell em Dean, you tell em.

[LacedUp]

No it doesn't Deano, no it doesn't.

Only our cards matter pal, and on our cards it's a sure fire L for Khan't(this was pure hilarity and ingenuity as per from you Dean).

Tell em Dean, you tell em.

When you say 'our cards' who, in plural, are you referring to?

[Roy Jones Jnr]

Everybody knows that maidana would man handle khan in a rematch. Khan is declining as a fighter 2-2 in his last 4 fights. Meanwhile maidana is 4-0 3KOS and is hitting the peak of his career as a fighter. Amir khan is a one trick pony....fast hands and no chin.

Oh fa Sho, oh Fa Sho my mate.

Me and you also know Maidana manhandled Khan already, and beat him.

Khan is a one trick pony, whilst this new Robert Garcia trained Maidana has more tricks in his locker than Dynamo Magician.

[Roy Jones Jnr]

LMAO! but i thought slow plodding maidana was supposed to be tailor made for the fast flashy broner, what happend? But now that maidana won you quickly forget that hahaha.

As for the alexander/maidana fight...eh, alexander,120 clinches. next.

Another fight that doesn't really count, great work Southpawology.

A thread for another day....but if it wasn't for those 120 clinches(you sure there was only 120 mate? seemed like much more to me) Maidana win's by KO. For damn sure.

Says Maidana KO'd Alexander on the Boxrec page i see.

[Roy Jones Jnr]

of course it counts. but for what it's worth...i scored khan vs maidana 1 point in favor of chino. good, close fight. i would prefer they rematch at welter. maidana would win IMO but its a much more competitive fight than either of them vs mayweather.

You scored it a win for Maidana on points, i scored it a win for Maidana by KO.

See a recurring pattern here Khan't fans?

[Roy Jones Jnr]

I had Khan winning by KO2 on my card.

Khan won and he'd win again.

Your card doesn't matter doe, your from Australia.

Mine does.

Deal with it.

[Roy Jones Jnr]

well, khan was fighting maidana, but maidana was fighting khan AND joe cortez. even after the fight maida said that at some point he thought tha cortez was gonna start punching him too.

Was gonna START punching him??

I'm pretty sure Cortez landed a few overhand rights himself in round ten when he jumped in to save Khan so many times.

I think Maidana knew that he was fighting two guys in there which made him sick to his stomach, with a bit of sick reaching his liver so when Khan punched him there that might have been the reason why Maidana went down in the first round.

[Roy Jones Jnr]

When you say 'our cards' who, in plural, are you referring to?

Mine(obviously) and Dean's.

You jelly?