which ATG could prime Cotto beat?

[techliam]

I think a prime Cotto beats both Floyd and Pacman at 147. I also think all 3 still lose to a prime Margarito (plastergate) in tact.

This. Pac vs Cotto prime for prime would be 50/50 for me though, those styles together are hard to judge

But I see a Prime Oscar beats all of these

[way2strong]

This. Pac vs Cotto prime for prime would be 50/50 for me though, those styles together are hard to judge

But I see a Prime Oscar beats all of these

would that make shane mosley GOAT?

[baya]

he beats kostya IMO, too slick too powerful too puerto rican

[techliam]

would that make shane mosley GOAT?

No but I see what you are trying to do

[Puya]

If Margarito Beat Cotto down pretty sure quite a few ATG like Chavez sr would have Medrick Taylor'd him inside of 6.

Margarita without that chin and the plaster we would not be talking about him

[Sugar Adam Ali]

If Cotto could beat them in their prime in their best weight class then I don't think they would be all time greats. I consider Cotto a very good fighter who is very popular and he has a crowd pleasing style. I don't think he is an all time great but I am sure lots of his fans think he is an all time great.

this ^^^^^^^

Cotto is a great fighter to watch, good fighter, but not ATG material. big fan of cotto, and he had a great career, but i dont see him beating any ATGs..

[Sugar Adam Ali]

I shudder to think what would have happened to cotto, had he ever met a prime tito, prime donald curry, prime ray robinson, prime leonard, prime hearns, prime benitez,

[Sugar Adam Ali]

If i had a gun to my head, i would say that cotto has the best chance of beating at 147

Barney Ross
Jimmy Mclarin

History section guys will hate me for saying that, but thats how i feel

[Doctor_Tenma]

Cotto would have never beaten Pacquiao, Floyd and likely not even a prime Margarito although that's a more winnable fight. His determent was not using his right hand enough and leaving himself open down the middle especially for uppercuts. I've always felt if Cotto would have fixed some things he could have been great but for now I'd say he was a very good fighter in his prime, definitely not great.