What level fighter is Broner?

[Anthony Birts]

Discuss.

[Mike D]

Glorified C fighter

[The Problem Child]

Right now, judging on what he's shown against the type of competition he has fought, a C+. And I feel I'm being a bit generous giving him that. C level fighter who because of his attempt at a philly shell has fooled some into believing he belongs at a higher level. Same story with Berto but I would rate Berto a C-.

[Shaniqua]

Broner's A+ he just got caught by that cheatin ass meydana.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

I would rate him as a B level fighter

A- elite p4p type guys-floyd ward, jmm, manny, tim

B- Championship level fighters- lucas, maidana, broner, ggg, bute, kovolev

C- solid journeymen like a collazo,sotokarass

D- Club fighter like peter mcneely

F- losing record type fighter, reggie strickland type


Broner looked bad vs maidana, but i think he is still a championship level fighter, and deserves to be on major networks

He is a low B-,,, whereas a guy like GGG or kovolev would be B+ type fighters

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Broner is one bad loss away from being a C level fighter in my eyes, just like how i rate berto right now,, C-level

[AgainstTheRopes]

He's B- level at 147. He was a solid B/B+ at 135.

[Oasis_Lad]

I'll be Generous and give him a C Rating.

[Pez]

He's still a talented fighter but I think he needs to move back down. B+

[New England]

at 147 he looks extremely pedestrian. i think it's being lost that he looked spectacular only when he was at 130 and 135.

b-. i don't think that's too critical after an asskicking from marcos maidana.


he's young, and could possibly improve. i don't think he will, though. he's too immature to admit that he needs to change.