Comments Thread For: Examining The Broner-Maidana Scorecards

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Mikhnienko
    Lomachenko P4P#1
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • May 2009
    • 6056
    • 413
    • 473
    • 13,966

    #11
    The thing that shocked me most about this fight was the scorecards being reasonable. Judges doing their god damn job bravo to you three.

    Comment

    • kardsufur
      Undisputed Champion
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Sep 2013
      • 3861
      • 146
      • 127
      • 10,355

      #12
      Originally posted by Lou Cipher
      Analyzing the cards is just a weak attempt of creating doubt or the illusion of competitiveness. Maidana broke that b!tch's ass. Thats the final score.
      greatest post ever with best avi ever

      Comment

      • H.B.Viper
        Contender
        Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
        • Aug 2013
        • 373
        • 22
        • 170
        • 9,925

        #13
        Telling freinds last night if they robbed

        El-Chino of this great victory, it would be a crime committed against everyone who ever worked hard into anything they have ever done in their lives.
        We would curse the state of TX, the commissioners who run the board, GBP, SHO, the local promoters, G.W. Bush, and everything evil in life!

        Maidana, would have been another innocent victim of this corrupt sport!
        Finally truth, justice, and a two fisted attack prevails in this sport!

        Comment

        • LOWBLOW_CHAMP
          P4P THE BEST AROUND
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Sep 2010
          • 1874
          • 52
          • 68
          • 8,813

          #14
          Originally posted by Mikhnienko
          The thing that shocked me most about this fight was the scorecards being reasonable. Judges doing their god damn job bravo to you three.
          wasn't really too tough to tough to score cus of broners inactivity, he let chino do 2x the work he did and all he did mostly was fight to survive and not win

          Comment

          • manimgoindown
            Contender
            • Feb 2012
            • 187
            • 16
            • 18
            • 6,723

            #15
            Not too far off from my own. I gave Broner more rounds than the judges maybe because I give more credence to landing clean shots over their impact. The judges clearly thought the latter.


            Maidana scored first

            1:10-9
            2:10-8
            3:10-9
            4:9-10
            5:9-10
            6:9-10
            7:9-10
            8:9-8
            9:10-9
            10:10-8
            11:9-9 (close round, maidana gcaught up landed a lot more clearly on the body)
            12:9-9 Broner busier earlier but missing or having Maidana block most of the shots, Maidana landed the more effective shots, bouncing left hooks off his face
            Total:113-109 Maidana
            Disgusting display of sportsmanship by Broner.

            I might have messed up the latter part of the scorecard but hopefully made the right fix.

            Comment

            • John Barron
              BIG LEAGUE GUY
              Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
              • Nov 2010
              • 9338
              • 865
              • 170
              • 49,338

              #16
              the only round i remember giving to broner cleanly was the 12th. he might've stolen a round or two between the 4th and 7th. clear victory for marcos.

              Comment

              • -Kev-
                this is boxing
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Dec 2006
                • 39914
                • 5,025
                • 1,447
                • 234,543

                #17
                Originally posted by H.B.Viper
                El-Chino of this great victory, it would be a crime committed against everyone who ever worked hard into anything they have ever done in their lives.
                We would curse the state of TX, the commissioners who run the board, GBP, SHO, the local promoters, G.W. Bush, and everything evil in life!

                Maidana, would have been another innocent victim of this corrupt sport!
                Finally truth, justice, and a two fisted attack prevails in this sport!
                Perks of joining Al Haymon is you are pretty much going to get fair scorecards. He is made out to be evil or something but the way Santa Cruz spoke about him and how he wouldn't be where he is without Haymon he sounded very genuine, that shows Haymon is not the "evil black activist" pro-Top Rank fans make him out to be. He's in charge of all of these Hispanics careers and doing a great job with getting them dates, Garcia, Lara, Maidana, Arreola, Matthysse, Santa Cruz, Lopez, Figueroa.

                Comment

                • Jack Napier
                  Whores on Our Cul de Sac
                  Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                  • May 2010
                  • 8668
                  • 812
                  • 424
                  • 16,030

                  #18
                  Maidana won most of the rds
                  he won them with decisively and with damage
                  he scored a couple KD's, and mighta had a 10-8 rd or 2 without KD's
                  thought for sure the judges were gonna rob him too
                  only surprise with the scores is that they were spot on

                  Comment

                  • Spray_resistant
                    Edgelord Champion
                    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                    • Feb 2009
                    • 29159
                    • 2,702
                    • 1,439
                    • 53,384

                    #19
                    Yeah thats nice but that is not how boxing is scored with averages of possible rounds won on whoever's card.....Maidana clearly dominated most of the fight......very poor article.

                    Comment

                    • danktrees
                      Contender
                      Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
                      • May 2005
                      • 371
                      • 32
                      • 1
                      • 7,079

                      #20
                      Originally posted by Mikhnienko
                      The thing that shocked me most about this fight was the scorecards being reasonable. Judges doing their god damn job bravo to you three.
                      and in texas no less!

                      i dont understand how the 8th round could have been scored 9-9 though, that was clearly a 9-8 round for maidana.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP