Top Five Boxers in the world. IMO

[checkhuk44]

Why is this thread even this long. The guy has mikey as #2 ffs lol. Thread invalid from the get go. Stop feeding the troll

Yet again. A poster being critical but not really taking the time to contribute to the discussion. Lazy

[pnksntdead]

Before Broner fought Demarco alot of you guys were saying that would be his test, HE BLEW HIM OUT AND you guys "moved the goalpost"
Like it or not the FACT IS MANNY IS 1-3 in his last fights. YOU DONT MOVE UP P4P WITH A RECORD LIKE THAT (be lucky i threw you guys a bone, he's responsible for almost half the loses on the list alone)

Broner got lots props for the DeMarco win but his showing against Paulie was a let down. I like Paulie but he's a gatekeeper. Broners underwhelming performance took some out of his luster so he had to flash his cawk online to gain some attention. I think he beats Marcos but that doesn't make him lb for lb.

How is manny 1-3 in his last three fights? I'm guessing that you gave him a loss in jmm 3 (controversial official win) but counted his loss vs bradley (extremely controversial loss). And you complain about people moving the goal post, lol.

Manny popped bradleys cherry while losing to another lb 4 lber (in a fight he was aheag in before getting ko'd) who he has always struggled against stylistically. Broner struggled all night to win against Paulie. How many will beat Manny at 140 - 147 vs how many will Broner?

[checkhuk44]

That is why I put Kovalev in my top-10--overrated boxers in the other thread !



Anyway, my top 5 are :

1- G.Rigondeaux
2- S.Martinez
3- W.Klitschko
4- T.Bradley
5- A.Ward

.
.
.

6- M.Garcia
7- B.Hopkins
8- F.Mayweather
9- N.Donaire
10- M.Pacquiao

P.S.
I put Donaire in both my top-10 boxers and my top-10 overrated because this is what I am really believing !
he is a very good boxer, I even favor him to win a clash with M.Garcia ! but he wasn't/isn't the best in his division, he wasn't/isn't top-5 P4P boxer !

In 5 years as a boxing journalist, that's by far the worst
Top ten I have ever seen. SMH

[Young Stribling]

People need to lighten up. A smidgen of humor never hurt anyone

Yes, but levity with brevity.....and remember, BREVITY should always trump levity.

[Jloro]

Yeah right! No way. Mickey eats him for breakfast

Yeah he just goes life and death in his last fight with the king of FNF while Danny beat down Matthysse lol

[checkhuk44]

Yes, but levity with brevity.....and remember, BREVITY should always trump levity.

1000000% disagree

[checkhuk44]

Yeah he just goes life and death in his last fight with the king of FNF while Danny beat down Matthysse lol

Life and death? That's a bit over the top. Watch the fight

[Jloro]

Life and death? That's a bit over the top. Watch the fight

Alright, dropped early and tagged at will

[checkhuk44]

Alright, dropped early and tagged at will

You def did NOT go back and watch the fight. you are making impossible statements right now

[rr00676]

Why is this so hard....


1. Floyd
2. Ward
3. Wlad
4. Rigo
5. Bradley