On a scale from 1-10 how do you rate Juan Manuel Marquez at 147?

[Larry the boss]

post and discuss

[Dirk Diggler UK]

When he fought Pacquaio.....10

When he fought Mayweather.... -37

[FrankieClutch]

He's a solid 7 at 147. Clearly isn't his best weight, I'd like for him to go down to 140 if he continues his career.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

he can fight well vs smaller welters like himself,,

vs manny, bradley, khan, broner, pauli he probably has good fights,,


vs full fledged welters like thurman, abregu, floyd, ortiz, ghost i think he struggles badly

[way2strong]

he's crap and would not have had a victory if it wasnt for a desperate punch .. manny also won number 3 clearly but that was at 145 I think .....

[Jcsuper]

he's crap and would not have had a victory if it wasnt for a desperate punch .. manny also won number 3 clearly but that was at 145 I think .....

get tfo son

[altparm]

At 147.

With roids he's a 9 (Manny 4 fight as proof)

Without roids he's a 3 (Bradley, Floyd, Manny 3 fights as proof)

[Beercules]

I think Juan beats Bradley in a rematch. Sounds crazy but it seemed he was figuring Bradley out late. Didn't Juan land 6 more power punches or something? Can someone post the stats?

I think Juan is a 7. He struggles with bigger welters as a previous poster said, but to be fair Floyd fought the worst JMM possible. Fat, throwing rocks off mountains, drinking pee.

[way2strong]

I think Juan beats Bradley in a rematch. Sounds crazy but it seemed he was figuring Bradley out late. Didn't Juan land 6 more power punches or something? Can someone post the stats?

I think Juan is a 7. He struggles with bigger welters as a previous poster said, but to be fair Floyd fought the worst JMM possible. Fat, throwing rocks off mountains, drinking pee.

bradley rolled with most if not all of jmm's punches he was clearly 3 steps ahead

[Ham Porter]

Mediocre. With Pacquiao he had the benefit of being in there with a guy who he knew better than Pacquiao himself and that sort of nullified the fact that he was older, a little more shopworn, and 20 pounds above his prime, optimum weight.


He definitely prepared himself better for the jump up in weight against Pacquiao than he did for the Mayweather fight, though.