Manny or Floyd: Who's had the best opponent in last five fights?

[Larry the boss]

I remember when this forum was all on the "FLOYD DOES NOT FIGHT TOP WW'S KICK" THEN THEY SAID "ALL HE FIGHTS IS OLD MEN" yet here we are praising Manny for fighting none ww's and old men

[revs1227]

accidentaly voted for marquez but it was bradley w/o a doubt
IF YOU THINK CANELO IS A BETTER FIGHTER THAN TIM BRADLEY IN ANY WAY SHAPE OR FORM PLEASE KIL YOURSELF

bradley
marquez3
marquez 4



very far behind is



canelo
cotto
gueero

i actually think bradley woul beat manny easily now
ortiz mosley

[Tylotto]

How I would put it is would Manny go unbeaten against Floyd's last five at the time Floyd fought them? I know Folyd ud's Mannys last five.

[hhs661]

Manny has the best fight with Bradley but he lost(i think he won). the fight. The fourth with JMM was unnecessary and he lost, bad. His third fight with JMM was ok and i felt he lost that one. The Mosley fight was a joke and this Rios fight was maybe worse.

I think Floyd takes this but it's nothing to brag about.

[jetgizo]

You can't say because he had wins at 154, he was a good champion at 154. Who did he beat? Foreman, Mayorga, Margarito. Two of those dudes were shot, and Foreman was a paper champion, who beat a shot Daniel Santos. Therefore, Cotto was a paper champion at 154. Marquez and Bradley were P4P fighters when Pacquiao faced them. Cotto was not P4P when Floyd faced him.

I never said he was a good champion. I said he gave Floyd his most competitive fight in years. I also said it was obvious to me JetGizo. Not me spark man. I can go and pick apart Bradley's resume like you did Cotto. Everybody on this site calls Alexander a bum why should I praise Bradley when he's knocked more people out with his head than with his fists.

[mofrekinfoe]

About even! Does it matter if Pacquiao lost to the same man that takes up 2 slots on that list? If not it's pretty even.

[RespekonMyName]

and trout be who to earn the key? washed up 147 pound cotto?

All a fighter can do is fight the best available guy. That was Trout.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

I remember when this forum was all on the "FLOYD DOES NOT FIGHT TOP WW'S KICK" THEN THEY SAID "ALL HE FIGHTS IS OLD MEN" yet here we are praising Manny for fighting none ww's and old men

jmm still fights at a very top level against top competition and has stayed active,,
Now if he sits out a year and some months and bradley or manny fight him, then i will call them out for it,,

but jmm was a top fighter in the world

shane was old vs manny, i always said that,,

Yes im sure their are some manny fanboys that contradict themselves but im pretty sure floyd fanboys like yourself do the same,,,

and the top welters from 06-13 have been cotto, margs, floyd, manny, williams

floyd hasnt fought any of the top 5 welters,,

You can go by the "rankings" but they are garbage hence why amir khan is #2

and 5 years from now,, idiots will be like khan was #2 ranked, canelo was #8 p4p, ghost was #10 p4p, etc like a bunch of idiots that dont possess critical thinking skills

[samouraļ]

Ok, really surprised at all the Canelo votes. Cotto, Marquez or Bradley are clearly better.

[T18Z]

Answer is clearly Pacquaio, no idea how you can rank Ortiz, Gurrero or Canelo better than Marquez or Bradley.