where would you rate Pacquiao on ATG list if

[Showtime..]

Funny to read all the past posts before these fights occurred.
He added undefeated Algieri to the list. Only one remaining is Mayweather.

His last 3 opponents were 83-1-1 before facing Pacquiao. Each in their Prime. Beating them @ 35 years old when he could had retired after JMM 4 is just icing.

[Bald Shavers]

Well, Pac already beat Rios. Then he dominated Bradley after Bradley won the title by beating Marquez. If Algieri goes on to do well against future competition, any win of his would add to Pac's legacy due to how easy it was for Pac to beat him. Algieri's win over Rusyan was Ring Mag "Upset of the Year."

For having done this, Pac moves up to top 15 pound for pound all-time. If Mayweather ducks him again, that could be counted as a win for Pac - hence putting him in the bottom half of the top ten greatest pound for pound ever.

he beats Rios
rematches and beats Bradley or Marquez convincingly
then fights Mayweather as his final fight and beats him before hanging up the gloves

[gamesworn]

Amazing accomplishments by Manny Pacquiao. A true All Time Great of this Era

1. Going up in Weights and winning in 8 divisions.
2. Winning 4 Lineal/Ring Titles against 4 credible Champions (Sasakul, Barrera, Marquez, Hatton)
3. Have amazing big fights among Barrera, Morales and Marquez and have two wins against each of them.
4. Considered as Mexicutioner in some point of his career.
5. Resume filled with future Hall of Famers.
6. Defeating WW/JrMW opponents in a more convincing way than Floyd while he's not a Natural WW.
7. Returning to top as a Top 2/3 P4P fighter after having a devastating KO loss.

On Topic: If he beats Mayweather, I'll put him on Top 10.

[Larry the boss]

Well, Pac already beat Rios. Then he dominated Bradley after Bradley won the title by beating Marquez. If Algieri goes on to do well against future competition, any win of his would add to Pac's legacy due to how easy it was for Pac to beat him. Algieri's win over Rusyan was Ring Mag "Upset of the Year."

For having done this, Pac moves up to top 15 pound for pound all-time. If Mayweather ducks him again, that could be counted as a win for Pac - hence putting him in the bottom half of the top ten greatest pound for pound ever.

Let me see your top 20 list

[Bald Shavers]

Let me see your top 20 list

Robinson

Ali

Pep

Armstrong

Greb

Louis

Moore

Ray Leonard

Duran

Roy Jones

Langford

Wilde

Gans

Pacquiao

Benny Leonard

Chavez

Monzon

Gavilan

Ezzard Charles

Canzoneri

[Wizardsh]

Let me see your top 20 list

Let me guess your number one is floyd?

[Robbie Barrett]

Robinson

Ali

Pep

Armstrong

Greb

Louis

Moore

Ray Leonard

Duran

Roy Jones

Langford

Wilde

Gans

Pacquiao

Benny Leonard

Chavez

Monzon

Gavilan

Ezzard Charles

Canzoneri

Roy Jones?

[Bald Shavers]

Roy Jones?

Can Rocky Marciano beat Roy Jones at 185 lbs.? No way.

Can Hagler beat Roy Jones at meet in the middle catchweight? No way.

Can Tommy Hearns and Sugar Ray Leonard beat Roy Jones at Super Middleweight? No way.

Can Michael Spinks beat Roy Jones at 175 lbs.? No way.

Remember, prime Roy Jones beat both James Toney and Bernard Hopkins and won a minor heavyweight title.

[Hype job]

Bald Shavers

[Showtime..]

Bald Shavers

I'm shocked he didn't put Tyson on the list.