Who's the Greatest ATG since Calzaghe Retired?

[LacedUp]

Not so sure Ward has better wins than Froch does

Bute
Kessler
Pascal
Dirrell
Abraham

--

Dawson
Froch
Abraham
Kessler
Miranda

It's close imo

yeah but Ward beat Froch.

[5.4ever]

Cal an atg??? I cant take this thread seriously now...

I hate how people are stuck on the "0" mentality

[Sam Donald]

loving the ali raymi jokes lol

[MRKilla]

Calzaghe isn't an ATG, he only beat a past prime Jones and past prime Hopkins, both in his prime will knock Joe out

What i was thinking...."since Calzaghe"...Then I see ol buddy avatar.

[boliodogs]

I didn't vote because I don't believe Calzaghe ever was the greatest. I rate him as an excellent fighter and better than Ward or Froch at 168. I think Mayweather, Pacquiao, Hopkins, Rigo, and Marquez will all be remembered in history as better fighters than Joe. Wlad and Vitali would be about equally as great as Calzaghe in my opinion.

[C.Y.]

Since when is Cal an atg? And Pac is a hof but certainly not an atg. His biggest wins are tainted in some way whether it be catch-weight victories over leftovers and guys coming off bad performances. Has not defeated an elite prime fighter without a catch weight or some sort of stipulation in his favor

[ji23]

calzaghe atg? when did this happen?

[Young Stribling]

calzaghe atg? when did this happen?

i don't see Calzhage as an ATG either. He didn't so much fight as ***** slap.

[Jloro]

Not so sure Ward has better wins than Froch does

Bute
Kessler
Pascal
Dirrell
Abraham

--

Dawson
Froch
Abraham
Kessler
Miranda

It's close imo

lmao he has Froch....

And answer to thread if talking about their whole careers it is Bhop clearly.
If talking about their body of work since Calzaghe retired it is probably Andre Ward imo.
Funny how they are like Father and son