Who's the Greatest ATG since Calzaghe Retired?

[Joeyzagz]

You can only judge based on fights that happened after 2008. So Hopkins wins over Trinidad and Tarver wouldnt count.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

manny, hopkins, floyd are the only ATG guys around now,,,,,

Ward is working on it, but not there yet,,


JMM is a great fighter HOFer but i dont think he is ATG IMO,,, he is like an honorable mention type guy: like camacho, tito,

[ModernTalking]

Ali...the one and only.

Move like a robot and hit like a truck.

[Holywarrior]

This is a bit confusing haha...um....wins from 2008 - on? Probably Pacquiao

[LeG00N]

Pacquiao
Marquez
Wladimir


in that order

[kurt0411]

Pacquiao, floyd and hopkins.

[LacedUp]

Ward imo. and quite clearly as well.

[Holywarrior]

Ward imo. and quite clearly as well.

Not so sure Ward has better wins than Froch does

Bute
Kessler
Pascal
Dirrell
Abraham

--

Dawson
Froch
Abraham
Kessler
Miranda

It's close imo

[nachorjj]

Calzaghe isn't an ATG, he only beat a past prime Jones and past prime Hopkins, both in his prime will knock Joe out

[Dr Rumack]

The Sanaa Assassin