Are these guys HoFers?

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Are these guys HoFers right now

Jermain taylor
Haye
Pavlik
Danny Garcia
Paulie
Rigo

Haye is the only lock i see,,, his domination at cruiser, plus a reign as heavy titlist, plus his fame and being able to land the huge fight with wlad,,, he should get in,,, he gave us some memorable fights like vs chisora,,,,, if he ko's fury then his odds are even better.......

Rigo is on his way but needs alittle more in terms of wins and longevity

danny might one day but he needs more time,,,,

pauli, pavlik and taylor are all no's,,,,, close but no cigar,,, pauli's best win is vs diaz or senchenko

pavlik and taylor looked like they would be locks but fell off and didnt have the longevity needed,,,, take away taylor's wins over hopkins and pavlik's wins over taylor and their resume is nothing special,,,, those are great wins but not enough to get into the HOF IMO

[$Bullsfam$]

Jermain taylor-Probably the closest with his wins over BHop even though their debatable. He had the career defining wins but not the longetivity and depth in resume so no.

Haye- Hell no. His best win is Chisora imo
Pavlik- Solid career but again had solid wins but fell off before he could cross over.

Danny Garcia- Too soon. He has solid wins like Taylor and Pavlik. Hes on the right track but we will see five years from now.

Paulie- No he was a good fighter but lost all his big fights.

Rigo- Too soon but he has the talent of one. This inactivity is killing him.




Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[$Bullsfam$]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jc8804

Are these guys HoFers right now

Jermain taylor
Haye
Pavlik
Danny Garcia
Paulie
Rigo

Haye is the only lock i see,,, his domination at cruiser, plus a reign as heavy titlist, plus his fame and being able to land the huge fight with wlad,,, he should get in,,, he gave us some memorable fights like vs chisora,,,,, if he ko's fury then his odds are even better.......

Are you fn kidding me? Your usually a solid poster but you have a few times here and there when you say some bizarre shiiiit like this.

His CW run was DECENT but CW has never been that great. Toney is really the only person who made the weightclass relevant and only for a couple fights.

Haye is the ultimate definition of a paper champion. Cherry picked Valeuv who is one of the saddest champs. Old Barnett and Ruiz who arent world beaters as it is, the fraudley win was a joke, and ducked and dodged Vital who would have killed him, talks his way to a shot vs Wlad talks all that noise and gives the worst performance ever running the whole time then blamed his toe.

If it wasnt for his win over a solid journeyman like Chisora I would say hes the biggest heavyweight hypejob of the last decade






Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[SkillspayBills]

None of them but Danny and Rigo have more time to stake their claim. It shouldn't just be a World champion being in the HOF the same way, in basketball, just because you were an All star once or twice you deserve to be in the HOF.

[CraigM]

Danny and Rigo have potential to be

Rest didn't do enough to come anywhere close

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Are you fn kidding me? Your usually a solid poster but you have a few times here and there when you say some bizarre shiiiit like this.

His CW run was DECENT but CW has never been that great. Toney is really the only person who made the weightclass relevant and only for a couple fights.

Haye is the ultimate definition of a paper champion. Cherry picked Valeuv who is one of the saddest champs. Old Barnett and Ruiz who arent world beaters as it is, the fraudley win was a joke, and ducked and dodged Vital who would have killed him, talks his way to a shot vs Wlad talks all that noise and gives the worst performance ever running the whole time then blamed his toe.

If it wasnt for his win over a solid journeyman like Chisora I would say hes the biggest heavyweight hypejob of the last decade






Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

Haye was an udisputed unified champ at cruiser,,,

and along with the heavy title reign, i think he will get in,,,, Not saying he is some ATG, but no doubt in my mind he gets in,,,,

the thing that hurts haye the most is inactivity,,, he should have had big showdowns with vitali, adamek, and others by now,,,,

I really dont disagree with any of your points,, i just think he will be a lock when he retires,,,, He has a huge name, was in some huge fights, and a 2 division champ,, that is usually enough to get in,,, Not saying he deserves it, but he will get voted in IMO

[GeneralZod]

Jermain Taylor is the only one you can make a case for right now. Future is a different story.