Is Zab Judah a HOF?

[toshmurph]

I don't see him as a first ballot HOF'er but I can definitely see him making Canastota second or third attempt

[Godsfly]

His best win is Cory Spinks, a guy who he's 1-1 with. Noway is he HOF, but there are worse fighters in there already so it doesn't take much more to get in.

well he has spinks who beat mayorga (Mayorga had just ko'd forest & was blazing hot at the time) mickey ward, corley, matthysse. a win over Malignaggi would be good..........

i don't think judahs resume is as poor as a lot of people think............

[A-Wolf]

Nope. The Baldomir fight is where he threw it all away. He acted like a bratty arrogant **** and almost got KTFO for his misdeeds. Then he crumbled after four with Floyd. The rest is history.

[Rome-By-Ko]

well he has spinks who beat mayorga (Mayorga had just ko'd forest & was blazing hot at the time) mickey ward, corley, matthysse. a win over Malignaggi would be good..........

i don't think judahs resume is as poor as a lot of people think............

I actually agree with this..

[GeneralZod]

Not in this life time.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

zab has had a good career,, the things that will help him is his longevity,,

good amateur career,,, olympian i believe or close to it,,,

had alot of solid wins at 140, and was a 3 time champ there,,

lineal welter champ,,,

fought a who's who of his era: ward, tsyzu, corley, spinks twice, floyd, baldomir, cotto, khan, lucas, clottey, danny,etc

one more big win, and he should be a HOFer,, not first ballot, but he will get in eventually,,,,
would have liked to seen him tangle with hatton, shane, corrales, castillo, morales, jmm, manny,

[_original_]

Absolutely not, he's not even borderline IMO.

[IronDanHamza]

If he does, then Baldimor does too

Not really.

Judah is a lot more accomplished than Baldomir.

[Oasis_Lad]

[Fighting_Pride]

right now? hell NO. the guy hasn't shown he could remain consistent. you what they say, you're only as good as your last fight.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android