Is Zab Judah a Hall of Famer?

[PAC-BOY]

His resume is underrated IMO.

But no.

Are you saying he has a good resume?

[Dorian]

No, but he can be in the Hall of Shame. Super bum!

[IronDanHamza]

Are you saying he has a good resume?

Not really. I think it's ok.

It's not as bad as others make out, IMO.

[-Kev-]

As Irondan says, his résumé is surprisingly underrated now, but no, I don't think so.

He actually has a few more good wins too.

Matthyse
Spinks
Terron Millett
Rafael Pineda
Kaiser Mabuza
Corley
Bergman
Witter
Ward

I like this guy, seriously. He adds names that are virtually unknown to the boxing public as good wins on a boxer's resume.

But yeah, surprisingly Mabuza doesn't get mentioned ever, despite Judah being underdog in that fight, as well as in the Paris fight.

Look at the abuse he got in the pre fight of Paris:

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=539100

[The Tase]

Are you asking this question for the sake of trying to make Cotto's resume better?

[revs1227]

he lost to matthysse

but he didnt .......

and no hes noth a hofer

[Mr Ehrmantraut]

I think he is.

He may not have won all his fights, but he literally fought anyone that mattered over the past 15 years.

[-PBP-]

He'll get consideration but will probably come up short.

[BlackSnakeMamba]

Yes

Gatti made it into the hall of fame. Judah beat better fighters than Gatti, and he also won more titles.

[SugarAnt05]

If you let Gatti in, you gotta let zab. I mean, can you even compare Gatti's resume to Zab's? I like both guys, esp Gatti war attitude but if Gattis in, Zab should be in too.