How did you score Mayweather/ Castillo I?

[-PBP-]

Wasn't a hard fight to score. Floyd easily won the 1st 5 rounds, Castillo finally picked it up and dominated the 2nd half of the fight, but Floyd did enough to pull out 2 of the last 7. I scored it 7 rounds to 5 for Floyd. I remember when the fight 1st happened, I was cursing the TV out at Larry Merchant for trying to make it seem like he lost lol, it was clear as day for me who had won, even more so evident in the rematch. Close fight, good fight. Castillo fought like a champion, but it was too late.

Associated Press had it 115-111 Floyd, Dan Rafael had it 114-114 and New York Daily News had it 116-111 Floyd.

Not really the signs of a "robbery". Just a close fight where the guy they wanted to win lost.

[Pacquiao'd]

I think it was 115-113...

That wasn't a robbery it was a clear Floyd win...

De La Hoya vs Mayweather was closer than that.

How when dlh oonly won 4 rounds being generous?

[J The UnBiased]

Associated Press had it 115-111 Floyd, Dan Rafael had it 114-114 and New York Daily News had it 116-111 Floyd.

Not really the signs of a "robbery". Just a close fight where the guy they wanted to win lost.

Trust me, the majority of the people here never knew who Castillo was. They heard some idiot say he lost the fight, they went to youtube and glanced at the fight, then said Floyd lost lol. It's about 4 people here who have actually watched the fight.

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

How did I see it? I saw it in 3D super slow mo and still thought Castillo won.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[cashdon]

Wasn't a hard fight to score. Floyd easily won the 1st 5 rounds, Castillo finally picked it up and dominated the 2nd half of the fight, but Floyd did enough to pull out 2 of the last 7. I scored it 7 rounds to 5 for Floyd. I remember when the fight 1st happened, I was cursing the TV out at Larry Merchant for trying to make it seem like he lost lol, it was clear as day for me who had won, even more so evident in the rematch. Close fight, good fight. Castillo fought like a champion, but it was too late.

THIS
I found it very hard to give Castillo any of the first 5 rounds if I remember one of them was close. Castillo came on latter rounds but it was too late. My scorecards were in tune with judges. I think I had it 116-112 with Floyd winning the rounds where points being deducted 10-8 and 9-9. If u scored the points deducted rounds differently like Lederman then I can see how you can come up with adifferent score. Let's not act like Lederman is infallible I've disagreed with plenty of his cards over the years. One thing that surprised me in this fight is something I don't think I've seen in ANY of Floyd's fights is him losing the championship rounds which he did imo in this fight. Competitive but clear win in my eyes for Floyd.

[J The UnBiased]

How did I see it? I saw it in 3D super slow mo and still thought Castillo won.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

you think Lucas never lost a fight before. We know you don't know how to score a fight.

[True Alpha Male]

Yeah I forgot, if you land more you won the fight right?

I agree with you for once....

Also I believe the compubox was BS, they were counting low blows and sheet. De La Hoya vs Mayweather was more competitive.

[True Alpha Male]

you think Lucas never lost a fight before. We know you don't know how to score a fight.

[MrTambourineMan]

115-111 for Castillo - The Right Score.

[ADP02]

Compubox doesn't judge a fight...

1 10-9
2 10-9
3 10-9
4 10-9
5 10-9
6 9-10
7 9-10
8 10-8
9 10-10
10 9-9
11 9-10
12 9-10

115-112 Floyd

Lederman is a terrible judge most of the time...

Yet you gave Floyd all of the first 5 rounds?