My pfp top 10 list of the best fighters today.

[King_]

Manny and Wlad don't belong on this list after their recent performances.

...... Yet Broner belongs on it after his masterful performance against the GREAT........




Paulie Malgniaggi

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Manny and Wlad don't belong on this list after their recent performances.

I wont argue that much,,, I just think manny lost to another p4p top 5 guy, and before that he beat bradley another top5 p4p guy

Wlad won ugly, but he still won easily,,, not every fight are you going to look spectacular,, broner is on your list and he struggled with pauli,, how do you justify that,,,,

[El Angel]

...... Yet Broner belongs on it after his masterful performance against the GREAT........




Paulie Malgniaggi

You don't think Broner is the greatest fighter of all time? Certified hater.

[dynomyte1444]

Id have wlad in place of boner even tho he stunk the place out in his last fight. wouldnt put broner in there just yet

I was thinking the same thing. You cant have broner over Wlad... no way

[Cuban Linx]

Carl Froch over Rigo?

How can anyone rank Froch in the P4P lists after the 2nd Kessler fight?

I respect Froch for what he's done in his career, but I'm seeing him rated way too high, not just on Frank's list, but on other lists as well. Ranking him no.7 is ridiculous, he's becoming overrated now.

[hugh grant]

Manny and Wlad don't belong on this list after their recent performances.

Why don't Pac make you top 10. He whitewashed Bradley literally over 12 rounds and was ahead of JMM before being Ko'ed. Any boxer can be taken out with one punch.

Bradley is no3 on the basis of controversially beat JMM and robbing Pac in a daylight robbery and going life and death with provodnikov?

[hectari]

I can understand Frank not having Manny there because technically he lost two fights, one by robbery and the other by clear cut knockout.

But removing Wlad for his performance? the guy still won. Why is it other guys can use that ugly style and get praised but Wlad can't?

[hugh grant]

I can understand Frank not having Manny there because technically he lost two fights, one by robbery and the other by clear cut knockout.

But removing Wlad for his performance? the guy still won. Why is it other guys can use that ugly style and get praised but Wlad can't?

But thats blinkered thinking and you need to be able to use your own discretion.

Pac whitewashed his no3 Bradley. So you should be able to dedeuce from that Pac is a top 5 fighter. Pac is fighting the top p4p guys. According to Frank Ducketts, Pac lost to two top 5 p4p fighters.
If you fight top boys and take risks you shouldn't be dropping down. You can fight unrated p4p fighters like Floyd fights in Canelo and Guerrero as much as you like and if you lose to guys like that you should drop below top 10.
Perhaps drop below JMM but that's it.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Carl Froch over Rigo?

How can anyone rank Froch in the P4P lists after the 2nd Kessler fight?

I respect Froch for what he's done in his career, but I'm seeing him rated way too high, not just on Frank's list, but on other lists as well. Ranking him no.7 is ridiculous, he's becoming overrated now.

I agree that you cant have froch over rigo,, but i have froch at #8,, yes he basically goes to war with everyone even an old kessler, but that is just his style, he is like a hatton, or cotto, where defense is not their speciality and no matter who they fight, the other guy will land and they will never pull off alot of Dominant performances,,, holyfield was the same way,, all he did was win, but he never could pitch shutouts like a floyd or hopkins could do

[Frank Ducketts]

I wont argue that much,,, I just think manny lost to another p4p top 5 guy, and before that he beat bradley another top5 p4p guy

Wlad won ugly, but he still won easily,,, not every fight are you going to look spectacular,, broner is on your list and he struggled with pauli,, how do you justify that,,,,

Broner didn't struggle with Paulie.