What fighters were not prime or at their peak vs Floyd

[WilkinsOlajuwon]

shane, zab, de la hoya. thats about it

and cotto.....

[The Big Dunn]

Empty attempt to distract the question. You are clearly just bringing up all the ridiculous things said about Floyd to cover up the genuine criticism that could be said about him.

if you think the TS criticism is either genuine or valid, then it says alot about you as a boxing fan and poster here on NSB.

[MrTambourineMan]

Corrales - Drained
Gatti - shot to pieces
De La Hoya - Past Prime
Marquez - Brought up from Lightweight, cheated on scales
Mosley - Shot to Pieces
Cotto - Past Prime
Hatton - should have been at 140
Canelo - Too Green

His best wins: Hernandez and Castillo in the rematch.

Every other name on his resume: Average fighters at best.

Floyd's career is a bunch of smoke and mirrors.

[WilkinsOlajuwon]

Corrales - Drained
Gatti - shot to pieces
De La Hoya - Past Prime
Marquez - Brought up from Lightweight, cheated on scales
Mosley - Shot to Pieces
Cotto - Past Prime
Hatton - should have been at 140
Canelo - Too Green

His best wins: Hernandez and Castillo in the rematch.

Every other name on his resume: Average fighters at best.

Floyd's career is a bunch of smoke and mirrors.

See this is where Floyd hate masks genuine Floyd criticism. This post is exaggerating. Chico always had problems with weight, that didnt stop him from demolishing everyone at 130 except Floyd. Shane wasnt shot to pieces.

If you want to objectively criticize Floyd do it without sounding like a rash hater.

[WilkinsOlajuwon]

if you think the TS criticism is either genuine or valid, then it says alot about you as a boxing fan.

See look, you are doing it again

You are allergic to anything negative about FLoyd. At least admit so.

Questioning who he fought that was not prime is not "hater" talk. Its a legit question.

[The Big Dunn]

See look, you are doing it again

You are allergic to anything negative about FLoyd. At least admit so.

Questioning who he fought that was not prime is not "hater" talk. Its a legit question.

It's a legit question, we agree. It has been discussed in roughly 1,000 threads here on NSB. The TS has given his opinion on the question dozens of times.

My point is look who is starting the thread. Do you really think the TS is being genuine?

BTW, did I use the word hater at all in either post?

[Frank Ducketts]

Nobody believes you guys because people tune in to Floyd's ppvs to watch these criticized fighters fight Floyd.

[Frank Ducketts]

Mosely would have finished him in his prime
JMM would have lost anyway
Hatton at 140 would have lost anyway
im not mad about DLH or Cotto.

How do you know that Shane finishes Floyd?

[joseph5620]

Canelo - far too young, hardly any top class competition, and catchweight
Cotto - well past prime
Mosley - Grandad
Hatton - would've been better at 140 than 147
Marquez - came up two divisions and got cheated on scales
Oscar - past prime

Off the top of my head.

Anything from the top of your head is coming from an empty shell.

[Jc8804]

Every fighter that floyd has ever fought has been either old or not prime. He has nevr beaten anyone worth mentioning. His percieved ATG status and p4p rankings are BS, its based solely on his cherrypicking and avoiding threats. As soon as he fights someone prime he will lose. He only sells ppv because of either the guy he is fighting or the semi main event.

He weigh cheated JMM, fought Hatton at his worst weight, Mosley was old and gassed, cotto was shot, ODH was shot and beat him. He lost to Castillo. Baldomir was slow. Canelo was drained at 152 and too young. He ducked Margs and Pwill as well as prime Kosta, casamayor, johnson, spafadora. He kept putting roadblocks up when manny wanted to fight.

He should fight GGG right now and not Martinez but wont because GGG is a threat. He wont fight outside of Vegas because he can't use xylocaine. He is gay, ellerbee is his boyfriend, and Ms Jackson gets double teamed by 50 and Victor Ortiz everyday.

Floyd lies about how much he makes. He'll be broke 2 years after he retires. He beats everyone in fantasy fights.

Ok, did I miss anything. Oh yeah, he testedpositive 3 times but its being covered up by USADA, which floyd controls.

When shane beat margarito. I think shane got to fight a tough strong fighter like himself . But he happened to be faster and
Was more explosive , and fought the perfect matchup vs guy with no defense.
Perfect fight for shane . He beat a come foward brawler
That was tailor made. Before that he looked average and aging.
He hasnt been prime since he got beat up by oscar in fight 2.

Shane then went on a layoff and then trained for berto for nothing.
Then went on a lay off and then fought a peak counter puncher .

Shane was shot . He likely overtrained. And he was old .
And his ring age was past it.

Those are facts