Are these fighters Hall of Famers?

[Larry the boss]

Miguel Cotto

Ricky Hatton

Sergio Martinez

Zab Judah

Antonio Tarver


are any??if so which ones are?

[AntonTheMeh]

with the exception of judah (who i don't think is)they're borderline.

[WilkinsOlajuwon]

will they get in or do they deserve to? two completely different quesitons

[-PBP-]

I think all of them get in. I think they are all deserving with Judah being borderline.

[Jack Napier]

Miguel Cotto

Ricky Hatton

Sergio Martinez

Zab Judah

Antonio Tarver


are any??if so which ones are?

Cotto and Hatton will get in, they're popular enough and did enough
fuck the rest of them, though Tarver is mildly underrated
he's known for Roy 2 but has some other good wins on his resume
Martinez is overrated and Zab's known as a loser

[IronDanHamza]

I wouldn't vote for any of them.

[Cardinal Buck]

Miguel Cotto

Ricky Hatton

Sergio Martinez

Zab Judah

Antonio Tarver


are any??if so which ones are?

Hatton will probably be first ballot.

Cotto gets in.

Martinez probably gets in.

Tarver is borderline but probably makes it, especially if he continues commentating, etc.

Judah probably not.

[New England]

cotto and hatton will probably get in to the hall of fame. tarver's going ot have trouble now with his PED trouble.


i'd have trouble voting for all of them. i wouldn't vote for judah for any reason. martinez either, really.

[VatoMulatto]

Antonio "Got any excuses tonight, Roy?" Tarver. Because of that classic line and the KO he delivered a few minutes later he should definitely get in to the hall of fame.

[SugarAnt05]

I loved Arturo Gatti fights. Always a fan favorite win/lose/draw he came to fight, but if you put him in the Hall of Fame, all of the above should be in the Hall of Fame as well.