(Recently) Who had a better showing vs Mayweather?

[bojangles1987]

I thought about putting Ortiz in there but since the end was so awkward I took it out. I mean he did good but he only had 4 rounds. I wish that fight would have lasted longer. Ortiz was the one guy going for BROKE.

Ortiz got beat up and frustrated so bad he quit in 4 rounds. Please.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Between the 3 of them they won a combined 3-4 rounds.

[CubanGuyNYC]

Cotto...and it ain't even close.

[r__mutt]

Cotto by a long shot...

Guerrero and Canelo are on about the same level for me. Guerrero was busier but equally neutralized by Floyd. Canelo was more patient - too patient - but simply couldn't convincingly win a round.

Ortiz probably had a better game plan than Canelo given his strengths, but he was much less successful than some people give him credit for (the headbutt clearly revealed his frustration). I doubt he would've had much of a chance down the stretch given Floyd's ability to adapt and Ortiz's lack of mental toughness as exhibited in the Maidana fight.

[DiegoFuego]

Cotto I think won 3 rounds against Floyd

Guerrero may have won one round (round 2?).

Canelo clearly lost all 12.

[Dorian]

Cotto by a long shot...

Guerrero and Canelo are on about the same level for me. Guerrero was busier but equally neutralized by Floyd. Canelo was more patient - too patient - but simply couldn't convincingly win a round.

Ortiz probably had a better game plan than Canelo given his strengths, but he was much less successful than some people give him credit for (the headbutt clearly revealed his frustration). I doubt he would've had much of a chance down the stretch given Floyd's ability to adapt and Ortiz's lack of mental toughness as exhibited in the Maidana fight.

Green k

[Queen_Leia]

Me too. He sure cherry picked his way into greatness

If I could make 41.5 million for 36 minutes worth of work, I'd cherry pick my to greatness too.

[BigZigga]

Cotto won two rounds. Canelo and Guerrero won 0 combined lol. Cotto takes this easily

[The Big Dunn]

Thought about putting Shane in here as well but besides that one punch he didn't do much.

JMM- 0 rounds won
Shane-1-2
Ortiz-0
Cotto-3 - 4
Ghost-0
Canelo-0

5 ROUNDS LOST SINCE RETURNING TO RING.

[BigZigga]

JMM- 0 rounds won
Shane-1-2
Ortiz-0
Cotto-3 - 4
Ghost-0
Canelo-0

5 ROUNDS LOST SINCE RETURNING TO RING.

so that's 4-6 rounds lost out of 52....crazy