(Recently) Who had a better showing vs Mayweather?

[Alx.]

Canelo doesn't even deserve a mention gave him max 3 rounds that could've gone either way, guerrero........ But Cotto had the most success

[Dorian]

Canelo had the most hype too. I def see lil Floyd retiring undefeated.

[spytactics]

Canelo had the most hype too. I def see lil Floyd retiring undefeated.

Me too. He sure cherry picked his way into greatness

[MindBat]

Cotto had the haters swearing up and down Floyd was old, shot, and had turtle-like reflexes.


.

[sbbigmike]

Polls are up.

Cotto only because Mayweather walked into the ring with a total disrespect for him and his power, and still Guerrero won more rounds he won at least 2 and arguably 3 rounds, one more than Cotto so .............




Better showing defintiely Cotto, who the most rounds Guerrero, Floyd definitely had the most respect for Guerrero than the other 2

[Dorian]

Cotto only because Mayweather walked into the ring with a total disrespect for him and his power, and still Guerrero won more rounds he won at least 2 and arguably 3 rounds, one more than Cotto so .............




Better showing defintiely Cotto, who the most rounds Guerrero, Floyd definitely had the most respect for Guerrero than the other 2

Cotto's the only one that caught him with clean hard shots here and there.

He easily dispatched all. Unbelievable.

[Beater_of_ass]

Anyone not voting Cotto is a tool, the last round Mayweather lost prior to the Cotto fight was the second round against Mosley and that was one punch. Floyd still took over that last minute on top of that. With Cotto, Floyd had to work his ass off every round and was getting hit to the body cleanly. Someone mentioned a Floyd rematch with Cotto... I'd watch it again, but only because it would be a good fight again and Floyd would still struggle. It wouldn't be a Canelo fight, Cotto would actually try to win, which to me Canelo did not he just looked like he wanted to stop being hit. I'd favor Floyd as I did their first fight, but I see it as a JMM/Manny rivalry in that the styles mesh well and make for entertaining fights. Besides Cotto has had the most success ever against Floyd IMO, he should get a second shot I give him a better chance than anyone else under MW.

[mezoomozaa]

Defenitely Canelo
he showed a GREAT performance against a better Mayweather version than Cotto fight's

[Dorian]

Anyone not voting Cotto is a tool, the last round Mayweather lost prior to the Cotto fight was the second round against Mosley and that was one punch. Floyd still took over that last minute on top of that. With Cotto, Floyd had to work his ass off every round and was getting hit to the body cleanly. Someone mentioned a Floyd rematch with Cotto... I'd watch it again, but only because it would be a good fight again and Floyd would still struggle. It wouldn't be a Canelo fight, Cotto would actually try to win, which to me Canelo did not he just looked like he wanted to stop being hit. I'd favor Floyd as I did their first fight, but I see it as a JMM/Manny rivalry in that the styles mesh well and make for entertaining fights. Besides Cotto has had the most success ever against Floyd IMO, he should get a second shot I give him a better chance than anyone else under MW.

Cotto appears to have fallen off since that fight.

[tito_bandito]

Cotto, Ortiz, Guerrero, and Canelo.