Just re-scored Mayweather Vs. De la Hoya

[FrankieClutch]

After watching DLH vs Mayweather live, I thought DLH won 7-5/8-4-ish. I think I was blinded by my hate for Mayweather at the time (and my bias for DLH). I've rewatched it probably 10 times after that and each time I scored it either 7-5 or 8-4 for May.

[boliodogs]

I think Floyd clearly beat Oscar and Judah. I thought Castillo won a close fight with Mayweather in their first fight. As you say Judah won a couple of the first 4 rounds and was out classed in every round after that and resorted to dirty fighting.

[therealpugilist]

He clearly beat Oscar and Judah...Both around 8-4 when I scored it. The Castillo fight I scored a draw the first time, 2 points the Mayweather the second time, and the last time a point by Castillo....the point deductions screwed up the fight for me....basically the fight was apples and oranges.....apples: pressure, body punches, and power shots oranges: clean shots, jabs, and defense


the cleared things in the rematch

[!! Shawn]

Did you watch the fight?? It's a very close fight, and it is well documented that floyd did have a hurt shoulder. I don't get paid to judge, but if you judge by pressure you would pick castillo, clean punching you would give floyd the nod. Either way he got the nod, gave a rematch and got the nod again. I can live with that..

THIS isn't a Mayweather\Catillo Thread..

Lets see these documents.

[daggum]

Lets see these documents.

floyd's word is ten times more credible than any legal document. if floyd said he was hurt he was hurt! when has floyd ever lied or been hypocritical?

[oneon11]

People keep saying Floyd lost the first Castillo fight, but I have a serious question for you all. If he lost why is it officially on the record as a win for Floyd? ???? I mean these clowns are trying to change an official ruling with just their thoughts. Sorry b ok ys and virls jt doesn't work that way... Hahahahahahahahahaha

[joeboy1983]

the fight was very close and is THE ONLY fight that any one can possibly give may **** about.. Everyone knows Mayweather earned the decision he got. My opinion is that after watching it I can see why folks would say it could go either way.

[Foreign Soil]

People keep saying Floyd lost the first Castillo fight, but I have a serious question for you all. If he lost why is it officially on the record as a win for Floyd? ???? I mean these clowns are trying to change an official ruling with just their thoughts. Sorry b ok ys and virls jt doesn't work that way... Hahahahahahahahahaha

Are you serious? The fight was in Vegas with HBO's backed Mayweather. Of course he's going to get the corrupt decision for the "good of the sport". Are you new to how things work in Vegas?

[RespekonMyName]

I agree that Mayweather clearly beat Oscar, but the Golden Boy made him work for it. Oscar's defense was pretty stout in this fight. Floyd couldn't get through clean most of the time.

Don't even bring up Castillo. JLC gave away too many early rounds.

[joeboy1983]

Are you serious? The fight was in Vegas with HBO's backed Mayweather. Of course he's going to get the corrupt decision for the "good of the sport". Are you new to how things work in Vegas?

Thats Texas buddy... And please learn the difference between close fight and getting robbed.