Comments Thread For: Mayweather Ranks 3rd on BoxNation All-Time Great Poll

[Mr.Smith]

This has to be a casual fans list. I didn't read the article once I saw Floyd at #3 I knew this list would be sad.

[SERVILEV]

This poll is hysterical! Obvious how starstuck most voter/fans know nothing about boxing ir the legends of yesteryears! The 2000s stardom limelight will never triumph the heart and courage of true ATG of the past. Media builds these guys up like superheros! Mayw? Calzag? Got to be kidding! In 20 - 50 years from now ppl wont have either guy anywheres nears the top!

[batista84]

Wicked List, all my respects to Ali, but in my opinion I would've put SRR as the no.1, the dude is a legend, Calzaghe on 10??? anyone........................?

Don't disrispect to Calzaghe but in my opinion and I'm sure a lot of Americans share my point of view, Chavez Sr. deserved more to be on that list that Calzaghe, and Phernell Whitalker is a monster too, I would've put him on that list too.

[black.ink]

As I have said a million times on this site. British fans are idiots, they don't know **** about boxing, and they ruined this forum when they started showing up in droves 5 years ago.

Calzaghe @ #10

******S!

Glad they cut it off at 10 so we didn't have to see Lennox Lewis at 11 and David Haye at 17.

Kirkland Laing is at 12. Motherfucker beat a prime Duran.

Brits know their shit.

[hitking]

To show you how much emotion Floyd generates. As much as Floyd shouldn't be #3, the fact that Tyson and Calzage are in the top 10 is far more absurd. Yet its getting minimal attenetion in this thread.

[The Tase]

a guy who has never faced a legit hall of fame fighter in their prime and whose best win is diego corrales is third all time?

[Reloaded]

Oh the butt hurt brigade are in pain LOL .

[Main Source]

I thought no one knew who mayweather was in england & europe... Read that quite often on this site... I guess we know they are full of s**t...

He actually has a strong fanbase in UK and somewhat in Scandinavia.

[Larry the boss]

lol,oh this is good

[komodo]

Calzaghe is too low.

That and no Lennox in the top 5....what the *** were they thinking?