Comments Thread For: Mayweather Ranks 3rd on BoxNation All-Time Great Poll

[SBleeder]

The results do not surprise me, assuming each voter can only vote once, many fighters would be overlooked.

For instance someone who believes Ali is the best, would not be able to vote for Hagler, Duran and so forth.

Which means there are people out there who think Calzaghe, Tyson, Floyd etc. are the best fighters of all time. Scary.

[Jc8804]

Lmao . Floyd at 3? Joe at 10????
Drop joe like 70 spots an floyd like at least
30 spots minimum.
Worst poll ever!!!!!!

[prinzemanspopa]

That's such a crap... It's like saying Sammy Sosa was an all time great baseball player during the summer of 98.... Gotta wait until after retirement to really put a career in perspective. A lot of people would say he already has losses to De La hoya and Castillo. All these other guys are long gone and its still a crap list. I don't think you could find a casual sports fan on the street who would put Mike Tyson in the top 10, let alone ahead of Joe Louis. Calzaghe is not in the top 10 either. Garbage.

Spastics would certainly say that.

[J The UnBiased]

Floyd at number 3 all time is crazy.......But Joe Calzaghe at number 10 is out right blasphemous lol.

[Fetta]

a Floyd fight in the UK would be massive and if this truly is his farwell tour then he should do it.

BTW #3 is ridiculous

[Bermuda]

lmao.....boxnation shouldn't boast about that poll...makes brits look like a bunch of floyd tards ....

[JaYDeuce11]

Wow are you f##### kiddin me? If avoiding your best competition without facing the toughest oppositions is top 3 worthy then all the past greats r rolling over their grave for the risks they took

Boxing back then,meverybody fought the best and even several times. They did not care about if they had a loss on their record, they just wanted to show and see how good were they. Floyd mayweather has been the complete opposite of that. His whole self preservation and 0!

Def top 25 but 3? Dd stephen a smith make ths list? Geesh...he onky gets tht spot if he oes on to defeat Canelo, Martinez, Pacuiao, Matthyse, . That least hes finally taking a risk with canelo

[J The UnBiased]

I do not think Roberto Duran is a top 10 fighter of all time....sorry.

[WilkinsOlajuwon]

Hahahahahahahahaha...............

[jlcelestine]

Mike Tyson and Floyd Mayweather are better than Joe F***ing Louis???