Carl Froch - Best win ?

[Sugar Adam Ali]

I started to vote for the Bute win which was a very impressive win.Then I remembered that the Kessler win avenged his loss so I voted for the Kessler win with the Bute win a close 2nd place.He fought very well in both of those fights.

The kessler win is barely a step-up from win cotto beat margs... both kessler and margs were past their prime..... in kessler's prime he beat froch in his prime...

[Madjab]

I don't see how some people can say Bute? I am of romanian nationality and i think he is a great fighter but mentally he isn't there, he folded when he felt froch's power and had the worst gameplan i've ever seen.

Not his fault Froch implemented his gameplan better. Froch's victory over Bute was momentus

[Dirk Diggler UK]

The kessler win is barely a step-up from win cotto beat margs... both kessler and margs were past their prime..... in kessler's prime he beat froch in his prime...

Absolutely terrible comparison.

[BafanaBafana]

I would say Bute, he was still fresh and in his prime (though he was ridiculously overrated and had a china chin). Kessler is a close second, but he was clearly well past his best. Pascal was extremely green and was never any good to begin with...

[Windmills]

Bute easily.

[BafanaBafana]

He has a few.

Between Pascal, Bute or Kessler I would say.

Taylor and Abraham were 2 fights he was a relatively wide betting underdog in.

Froch was pretty (completely in the States) unknown back then, the Taylor win was the one that first put him in the map. Taylor and Abraham were both career middleweights and neither were ever any good at super middleweight.

Abraham's best win or 'achievement' at middleweight may very well be his 12th round stoppage of Taylor. When you remove his tune-up and stay busy fights, Abraham's record at 168 probably reads 2-4 (1 KOBY).

Taylor's record at 168-170 is 1-3(2 KOBY) I think if you include the Pavlik II fight. His best performance at 168 was probably his loss to Froch where he actually had him hurt and down in the 3rd and was 3-4 points up on the cards going into the 12th.

Froch's best win is definitely between Bute and Kessler.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Nitpicking Carl Froch's resume

[daggum]

Froch was pretty (completely in the States) unknown back then, the Taylor win was the one that first put him in the map. Taylor and Abraham were both career middleweights and neither were ever any good at super middleweight.

Abraham's best win or 'achievement' at middleweight may very well be his 12th round stoppage of Taylor. When you remove his tune-up and stay busy fights, Abraham's record at 168 probably reads 2-4 (1 KOBY).

Taylor's record at 168-170 is 1-3(2 KOBY) I think if you include the Pavlik II fight. His best performance at 168 was probably his loss to Froch where he actually had him hurt and down in the 3rd and was 3-4 points up on the cards going into the 12th.

Froch's best win is definitely between Bute and Kessler.

could you break down joe calzaghe's resume for me(and dirk)