Brook vs Senchenko: BS Fight or not?

[New England]

I'm not sure little Broner would have an easy a time of it against a big strong 5'11 welter like Senchenko. Malignaggi was just a bad style match-up for VS. I don't think your triangle works.

broner would destroy senchenko. the guy was stopped by paulie malignaggi, one of the lightest punchers ever at the world level, who had never been close to stopping a ranked fighter.


the only reason this is considered a viable fight by any of the brits is the hatton angle. senchenko stopped ricky hatton. that's why this horrible fight will happen, and probably be relatively big.

[kiaba360]

Don't care about it, but it isn't any worse than his previous opponents.

[Weebler I]

Lol whos a better fighter, maidana or schenko? Seriously answer this question and be honest about it.

The question is who is the more difficult test for the 5'6 static Adrien Broner.

Broner might well beat both, but I think he has a tougher time with the bigger guy who stopped his last opponent to the body.

broner would destroy senchenko. the guy was stopped by paulie malignaggi, one of the lightest punchers ever at the world level, who had never been close to stopping a ranked fighter.

That triangle theory doesn't work because Paulie is a very different fighter to Broner.

Malignaggi moves around, Broner doesn't move, he's static and shells up when his opponent is on the attack to protect his head (leaving his body open).

Broner might well win but I don't think he has an easy night.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Oh and brook pushing the boat out is a problem ehh? The comoariosn is very legit because brook is long due for a step up. The excuses have run out. No1 is running scared of kell brook. There are better fights than schenko that can be made if anyone gave a damn to make them. Or I guess u are saying since he can't cherry pick a fighter like malignaggi, he should be free to fight a wuri level fighter? Is that your point. I fail to see it.

Malignaggi is looking at a Broner rematch. I'll use his own words just for you...."This is called PRIZEfighting you DUMMY!".

Paulie didn't want to fight a guy like Keith Thurman because the money wasn't good enough and that was on HBO in America. He isn't fighting Brook in Sheffield.

Brook has to do what he did with Devon. Work his way to a mandatory position to get a shot at a big fight. He can't handpick any fighter like Broner.

I'll agree with you, this is a disappointing fight but to compare it to Broner is just another sign that the butthurt is still strong in you over the criticism he gets. I actually like Broner but the whiny Mayweather fans like you are starting to latch onto him in the same **** way.

[Kagami Taiga]

The question is who is the more difficult test for the 5'6 static Adrien Broner.

Broner might well beat both, but I think he has a tougher time with the bigger guy who stopped his last opponent to the body.



That triangle theory doesn't work because Paulie is a very different fighter to Broner.

Stop bringing up styles in this convo. That only applies when u are actually a world level fighter. Getting stop by Paulie pretty much means u aren't a world level fighter. Get outta here with that. Sechenko is not a world level fighter. So his style means nothing.

EDIT: sorry for the typos, just reached my office so i can use a real keyboard now.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Maidana is Broner's mandatory. He's not going to give up a fight against Broner to fight Kell Brook.

Think about it.

[badnewsbrown]

Senchenko is definately NOT world class. You can even forget about what has happened in the past, just take a look at the guy for his skills, do the eye test. He's just not good.

[bigcursedawg]

The fight with Paulie was stopped because of Senchenko's eye. People on hear are acting like Paulie put him to sleep. Hatton stopped Paulie, Paulie stopped Senchenko and Senchenko stopped Hatton in a horrible tune up gone bad.

Senchenko is one of the biggest active ww's and is definitely a step up from Jones. Brook has never had to deal with a boxer that has the size and reach of Senchenko. It's not a bad fight at all IMO.

[Weebler I]

Stop bringing up styles in this convo. That only applies when u are actually a world level fighter. Getting stop by Paulie pretty much means u aren't a world level fighter. Get outta here with that. Sechenko is not a world level fighter. So his style means nothing.

EDIT: sorry for the typos, just reached my office so i can use a real keyboard now.

lol don't worry about it.

Broner would get criticised for fighting Senchenko but he gets criticised regardless of who he fights.

This is not a small step. This is spinning your wheels In the mud. How you go from Alexander to this when there are so many others out there.

Some big announcement this is

He never got to Alexander though, he's going from Matthew Hatton and Carson Jones to this and I think it is step up, albeit a small one.

[Kagami Taiga]

The fight with Paulie was stopped because of Senchenko's eye. People on hear are acting like Paulie put him to sleep. Hatton stopped Paulie, Paulie stopped Senchenko and Senchenko stopped Hatton in a horrible tune up gone bad.

Senchenko is one of the biggest active ww's and is definitely a step up from Jones. Brook has never had to deal with a boxer that has the size and reach of Senchenko. It's not a bad fight at all IMO.

did, u see the fight?? paulie also busted his nose and beat him brutally. not to mention this also happened on his home turf. sorry but sechenko was lucky to win more than a round or 2 and he took a beating at the hands of possibly the most feather fisted world level fighter in boxing.