Maidana vs Broner. Who wins?

[Syf]

No hate here...

What evidence do you have that Broner can **** with such a big puncher? And, what proof of surviving adversity does Broner have that compares to the multiple examples of Maidana's warrior's heart?

Broner is, after all moving up from lightweight to face a featherpunching Malignaggi... Then on to face one of, if not the, hardest puncher/s in the division?

[shenmue]

No hate here...

What evidence do you have that Broner can **** with such a big puncher? And, what proof of surviving adversity does Broner have that compares to the multiple examples of Maidana's warrior's heart?

Broner is, after all moving up from lightweight to face a featherpunching Malignaggi... Then on to face one of, if not the, hardest puncher/s in the division?

None, that is what makes Maidana a tough test for Broner and why i want to see it. maidana would land some clean shots on Broner, Broner isn't a defensive wizard like Floyd or a runner/holder like Devon is.

Make the fight GB.

[malcolm]

Easy fight, Easy payday for BRONER!

Maidana is not very good. Period. He made Joseito Lopez look like Ray Robinson for majority of their fight.

Broner would end this guys night in 5 or less. Dancing and clowning the entire time.

[soul_survivor]

That's a good fight, it's hard to predict a winner because we don't know how Broner will react to getting hit by a huge puncher at '47. On paper, it appears Broner should win, but it's an interesting fight and Maidana will test him. Adrien Broner is good defensively but he's not that good and will be hit with clean shots from Marcos.

Exactly! No one has any idea how Broner does at 147, he has skills but lacks foot speed, which I'm guessing decreases even further at ww, having said that I can only see his power increase and we know Maidana can be hurt. Then again Rene has survived against bigger punchers so I think he has the ability to seriously hurt the smaller Broner, damage him, rough him up and possibly stop him.

But I'm saying it now, Broner goes down to 140 or 135 after Paulie, if he stays up and fights Maidana, win or lose he gets mad props from the hound dog!

[sicko]

I think Broner would tear Maidana apart inside far worse then Alexander did. But I have to see how he looks at 147 against Paulie first, I think he will have no problem carrying that extra weight though but we shall see. But as far a style goes I think Broner ability to fight inside and roll and counter from inside the pocket is the perfect style to deal with Maidana Powerful Style and he is also not hard to hit either

[John Barron]

Broner skilled but a little too stationary. If guys like Gavin Rees can hit him clean, Chino can. And if guys like ponce spell trouble for him, then a well conditioned, focused Maidana is too much.

Unless Broner can get on his toes more than I think and outpoint Maidana it will turn to a brawl, and that favors Maidana all the way.

those guys were able to hit him because he had no respect for their power, broner did whatever he wanted. i don't think he'll be as confident with marcos. though he certainly has the skill and ability to outbox maidana once he feels the punches.

[John Barron]

Easy fight, Easy payday for BRONER!

Maidana is not very good. Period. He made Joseito Lopez look like Ray Robinson for majority of their fight.

Broner would end this guys night in 5 or less. Dancing and clowning the entire time.

by majority do you mean a round and a half? oh and getting dropped then stopped in 6 rounds? a real ATG performance right there.

[Nicolino]

This fight would be great opportunity for Chino to expose another hype job. it would be like the Ortiz fight all over again. If Chino uses that heavy jab just like he did against Soto Karass, Broner has absolutely no chance of winning that fight. Broner's footwork is not enough good to avoid Maidana's punches. So far Broner beat up smaller guys, staying in front of them and trading.

[RiC-DiC]

Broner by UD.

Adrien is stronger, faster, slicker than Khan. Maidana is too one dimensional and would get outboxed all night.