Biggest Career Disappointment Kirkland/Guzman/Gamboa/Dirrell?

[BoxingAddict773]

Imma have to go with Kirkland....i mean dude really could've easily been a top draw in the sport. A woman training him would have also made for a great "gimmick" even tho it wasnt one, if u get what I mean. It's something that could've made him stand out like Canelo being a red headed mexican. Gamboa is number 2 for me...I mean look at who he is fighting next...wtf...he had WAY WAY more buzz than Rigo now Rigo is getting the shine and Gamboa is barely a remembered name. Shame on you 50 Cent

[Sugar Adam Ali]

I gotta go with Dirrell, He had all the talent and pedigree and hype and just wasted it with inactivity..

Kirkland a close second because of all his out-of-ring issues

Guzman just never had the right promoters to land the bg fights vs manny etc

Gamboa - needs to stay active,,

[yoz]

Dirrell, without doubt.

[#YOLO]

Guzman by far

[Sugar Adam Ali]

At least guzman and gamboa won world titles...

Kirkland is exciting but not very good vs top level guys, so its hard to call him a bust when nobody expected him to become an elite fighter, he is just very exciting

Dirrell had the pedigree to be on p4p lists and become a champ, but he doesnt have the mental makeup to reach that elite level like an andre ward or carl froch does

[Sam Donald]

good thread... dirrel

that dude completely flopped

gamboa missed out on rios and a potential broner fight

kirkland wasnt that good

guzman was okay but wasnt a big deal as the others in terms of hype

[THE REED]

Dirrell/Gamboa > Kirkland mainly because of the talent seperation.

Though both still have a future, Dirrell more than Gamboa... imo

[Porter's Dad]

Gooz. He was super-talented.

[KillaMANE704]

1 Andre Dirrell- the only fight cuda gave ward problems jst mentally weak
2 Gamboa - Had one of the biggest buzz in boxing lost it by not fighting, now he rusty
3 Kirkland - Beat angulo for nothing
4 Guzman - Done more than the other 3, but ****ed up with weight issues( seen his last fight)

[SugarAnt05]

Guzman by far because out of all of them, he had the greatest talent but wasnt professional enough to make weight in some of his biggest fights.