Who did better against Judah : Matthysse or Garcia?

[BornToLive]

Garcia did because Matthysse had a horrible habit of starting slow. He doesn't do that anymore.

It wasn't a horrible habit, it was Matthysse first 12 rounder...he wanted to pace himself. If Matthysse had a few 12 rounder's under his belt prior to the Judah fight....he would've won even more clearly.

[daggum]

judah actually won both foughts, in fact he beat floyd by dq after floyd's trainer entered the ring, he beat khan by dq after khan low blowed him, he beat cotto after cotto low blowed him, he beat clottey after clottey head blowed him, so basically he's an undefeated fighter

[SlySlickSmooth]

It wasn't a horrible habit, it was Matthysse first 12 rounder...he wanted to pace himself. If Matthysse had a few 12 rounder's under his belt prior to the Judah fight....he would've won even more clearly.

I could see that being a factor. I had Matthysse winning 115-112 against Judah, but it was close and scoring in boxing is what it is. Matthysse showed some chin in this fight.

I saw a clearer victory for Garcia over Judah despite Garcia looking a little anxious at times and especially confused in the last rounds.

[Light_Speed]

Garcia, and he did it against a better version of Judah in my opinion. Matthysse is a better fighter though, all he needed was one adjustment through some of his struggles against Alexander and Judah, that was to start faster.

A better version Judah? This version of Judah had previously been beat up and stopped by Khan.

[piye]

One guy won and the other lost so the answer is clear.

[richardt]

You could also play a different angle and that was who was hurt more and drained more and that was Garcia. Judah punished Garcia way more than he did Mathysee. Garcia had more taken out of him.

[Rome-By-Ko]

Garcia by a long shot..

[Bushbaby]

Quite obviously Garcia.

[Light_Speed]

You could also play a different angle and that was who was hurt more and drained more and that was Garcia. Judah punished Garcia way more than he did Mathysee. Garcia had more taken out of him.

Apparently a lot of people don't take that into account...

[Ringlife]

I thought Garcia did he buzzed Zab a lot more during their fight.