Just watched Matthyse vs Alexander/Judah

[sebspeed]

Just watched both fights for the first time in my life. I don't know which one was supposed to be the closest, but I feel Matthysse was robbed from a win versus Judah... was close but easy to score.

Matthyse vs Judah
Round 1,4,5,8,12 for Judah and Round 2,3,6,7,9,10(+1kd),11 for Matthyse
Final Score: 115-112 Matthyse

Matthysse vs Alexander
Rounds 1,2,3,5,9 for Alexander and Rounds 4 (+1kd),6,7,8,10
Final Score: 95-94 Matthysse

I can settle for a draw in the Alexander fight, it was close.. But the Judah fight was a robbery.


What were your scores and your thoughts on both fights?

[-PBP-]

I thought the exact opposite of you. I thought the Alexander fight was a flat out robbery and the Judah fight was close.

[Ringlife]

I don't remember my scores but I had Matts winning both fights.

[The Big Dunn]

Just watched both fights for the first time in my life. I don't know which one was supposed to be the closest, but I feel Matthysse was robbed from a win versus Judah... was close but easy to score.

Matthyse vs Judah
Round 1,4,5,8,12 for Judah and Round 2,3,6,7,9,10(+1kd),11 for Matthyse
Final Score: 115-112 Matthyse

Matthysse vs Alexander
Rounds 1,2,3,5,9 for Alexander and Rounds 4 (+1kd),6,7,8,10
Final Score: 95-94 Matthysse

I can settle for a draw in the Alexander fight, it was close.. But the Judah fight was a robbery.


What were your scores and your thoughts on both fights?

Judah fight was a close loss, alexander fight was probably a close win but definitely not a robbery IMO.

[dde91]

i from what i remember i had the Judah fight closer then the Alexander fight. The Alexander fight to me he won at least 6 rounds (i think i gave him 7 tho) including the knockdown. so thats a wide margin.

[UTEP]

Wait, you had Alexander closer than Judah?

[Russian Crushin]

Both robberies

You got the Judah score right and the Devon fight was 6-4 Lucas at worst

[bojangles1987]

Judah has an argument, but I had Matthysse winning. I definitely feel Lucas deserved the decision.

The Alexander fight was a flat out robbery. Horrible. Anyone who thinks this fight could have gone to Alexander either wasn't paying attention, or has some bias for Devon or against Lucas.

[Salardo]

I haven't seen Judah vs Matthysse, but I remember I had Matthysse winning the Devon Alexander fight by 1 point. I remember everybody called it a highway robbery, but it was a very close fight and Matthysse edged it on my scorecard.

[Bigg Rigg]

Lucas got jerked on both fights.