Better Perfomance: Rigondeaux vs Donaire OR Haye vs Valuev?

[The Hammer]

Obviously Rigondeaux's performance was better.


Valuev was robbed against Haye.

Rigondeaux CLEARLY won against Donaire.

[gmc_rfc_06]

Obviously Rigo, that was a masterclass agaist a top oppoent. I have that as a 118-109 demolition.

I scored Valuev-Haye 117-111, that was also one-sided and a good performance from Haye IMO.

[damit305]

Rigondeaux KOs Valuev in 4. Size and weight don't matter here.

[elfag]

Was Valuev in the top 10 p4p like donaire was?

Was David Gaye in his 13th pro fight?

Did Donaire get outboxed by geriatric Evander Holyfield and not even deserve to still have his title?


Thats what I thought.

[The Smash]

Rigo against Donaire obviously.

He dominated a top 5 p4p in his prime where Haye questionably won against some 40yr old overgrown sloth which stunk out the whole of Germany.

Chagaev & a 48yr old Holyfield beat Valuev far more impressively than Haye did.

Hang on, haven't you spent the past 6 months telling us that Donaire is shit?

[gmc_rfc_06]

Hang on, haven't you spent the past 6 months telling us that Donaire is shit?

Well, he never said in his opinion.

He is stating the fact that Donaire was regarded by the vast majority as a top 5 P4P fighter.

[Szef]

Obviously Rigo, that was a masterclass agaist a top oppoent. I have that as a 118-109 demolition.

I scored Valuev-Haye 117-111, that was also one-sided and a good performance from Haye IMO.

You kidding me right? Valuev didn't lose that fight, beside one shot in final round Haye didn't do shiet.

For TA what kind of ****** question is that? Rigo outclassed and humiliated top 5 P4P guy , fighter of the year 2012 for **** sake. It's not even close

[gmc_rfc_06]

You kidding me right? Valuev didn't lose that fight, beside one shot in final round Haye didn't do shiet.

For TA what kind of ****** question is that? Rigo outclassed and humiliated top 5 P4P guy , fighter of the year 2012 for **** sake. It's not even close

LOL.

Valuev plodded forward ad hit nothing all night. Punchstats on this very site suggest he threw over 300 punches and landed 64, it was horrendous. Haye threw less than half and landed 34 more...hit and not get hit, you don't get points for walking forward and punching thin air.

[Szef]

LOL.

Valuev plodded forward ad hit nothing all night. Punchstats on this very site suggest he threw over 300 punches and landed 64, it was horrendous. Haye threw less than half and landed 34 more...hit and not get hit, you don't get points for walking forward and punching thin air.

Yes and you don't get points for jumping around your opponent. Haye did nothing to win.

[dan_cov]

Hang on, haven't you spent the past 6 months telling us that Donaire is shit?

No I never said he was ****.
I said he was overrated, not as good as everyone was making out, limited, had a poor defense, a bit of a one trick pony and Rigondeaux was better in just about every area and would school him. Everything I said came out on fight night.

I've always said he is a good, capable fighter but an overrated one who had only fought guys totally made for him.

But yeah he wasn't in my top 5 p4p list, he was barely top 10 not that I pay much attention to them.