How should P4P be determined?

[Build That Wall]

How should P4P be determined?

[techliam]

Any way you like.

I personally determine P4P on the colour of their gloves and shorts on fight night. Even then, my P4P isn't as shocking as other peoples

[Tim2daresq]

Activity, opposition, and results.

[KidGalvain]

Format needs to be changed.
It needed to be changed since the 90's..


The original concept of p4p is to glorify the lower weights Sub 160... because the heavyweights took up the vast majority of the star power...

That concept has become obsolete ever since the drawing power of the Fab Four came into play.

Lower weight superstars since the 80's are a common occurance now.. So p4p should have been and should be

QUALITY OF RESUME

and current p4p should be
RECENT QUALITY OF RESUME


And that's the bottom line.

[KickAzz]

whatever you want cause P4P lists are like arseholes... everyone has one

[wigg1]

Maybe it should be judged on a year to year basis. The most impressive fighter of the year would be crowned as a p4p top.

[KidGalvain]

Exactly it should be judged on a yearly basis.

There is no possible way you can justify Floyd at #1 for beating Cotto and that's it for the entire year.

When Trout beat Cotto even worst ......and Rigo beat Donarie.

It should be on a year to year basis.

[techliam]

Exactly it should be judged on a yearly basis.

There is no possible way you can justify Floyd at #1 for beating Cotto and that's it for the entire year.

When Trout beat Cotto even worst ......and Rigo beat Donarie.

It should be on a year to year basis.

Surely that's what fighter of the year is for.

The major flaw with this, is that, even if Floyd or Ward fought only once in a year, against an opponent not great, and say Rigo beats Donaire, it doesn't prove that Rigo is better than Floyd or Ward P4P. You need to base it on more than one fight to say look, Rigo is pound for pound better than Floyd/Ward. If they ever met at a hypothetical same weight, Rigo would win, and here's the list of fights to prove he can adapt and best their styles: ... you can't do that with just 1 fight.

[Build That Wall]

I bet people from other places have the Klitschko brothers 1, and 2 and they definitely would have a good arguement too.

[Build That Wall]

After the rankings Ring Magazine put out. I say no more P4P. It is just as pointless as the BCS rankings.