How's your Top 10 P4P look now???

[revs1227]

there is absolutley no way in hell mayweathers #1


andre ward is the best in the world


ward
marquez (beat the man )
martinez
rigo
floyd
pac
doanire
bradley

[baya]

there is absolutley no way in hell mayweathers #1


andre ward is the best in the world


ward
marquez (beat the man )
martinez
rigo
floyd
pac
doanire
bradley

this list is atrocious.

[Juanma9]

this list is atrocious.

Who in particular is missing and who gets the boot? You know, besides a Rigo Donaire in lieu of recent events.

[BafanaBafana]

there is absolutley no way in hell mayweathers #1


andre ward is the best in the world


ward
marquez (beat the man )
martinez
rigo
floyd
pac
doanire
bradley

What do you mean he's not the undisputed #1 P4P in the world? Over the last three years he has fought a shot Cotto (and got his nose crushed), quitter Ortiz (KO'd by Maidana later Josesito), and is soon to prove his P4P supremacy against Guerrero (looked like **** in his only two 147 fights). Who have the other P4P fighters fought in that same 3-4 year timeframe? lol

[Verstyle]

there is absolutley no way in hell mayweathers #1


andre ward is the best in the world


ward
marquez (beat the man )
martinez
rigo
floyd
pac
doanire
bradley

I actually like your list. Good job. No sarcasm at all.

[baya]

Who in particular is missing and who gets the boot? You know, besides a Rigo Donaire in lieu of recent events.

i feel that a universal measure for the mythical p4p list is longevity.

to not have may at 1 and not have hopkins in there AT ALL, is just insane.

[vacon04]

1. Mayweather
2. Ward
3. JMM
4. Martínez
5. Wlad K
6. Rigondeaux
7. Mares
8. Pacquiao
9. Froch
10. Donaire

[El Angel]

1. Andre Ward
2. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
3. Juan Manuel Marquez
4. Guillermo Rigondeaux
5. Sergio Martinez
6. Wladimir Klitshcko
7. Manny Pacquiao
8. Abner Mares
9. Carl Froch
10. Nonito Donaire

[Juanma9]

i feel that a universal measure for the mythical p4p list is longevity.

to not have may at 1 and not have hopkins in there AT ALL, is just insane.

I see what you're saying but in my opinion longevity is more important for comparing legacy. I'm not gonna deny that Hopkins is HOF material, but he doesn't make my p4p list simply because he's not the best in his division.

[Tim2daresq]

What do you mean he's not the undisputed #1 P4P in the world? Over the last three years he has fought a shot Cotto (and got his nose crushed), quitter Ortiz (KO'd by Maidana later Josesito), and is soon to prove his P4P supremacy against Guerrero (looked like **** in his only two 147 fights). Who have the other P4P fighters fought in that same 3-4 year timeframe? lol

Damn, you make some good points. Floyd should be #4-5.