So who will be remembered as the greater fighter, Pacquiao or Marquez?

[_Gatti_]

That's the tricky one don't you think?

No i dont think it is. Its not even close. Marquez is a great champion. But hes not on Mannys level of accomplishments!

[HeroBando]

Are you saying that a 145 pound Cotto win is the deciding factor on which of the two is superior to the other?

No but show me a fighter JMM beat, besides Pac, that would make it to round 5 vs 145lb Cotto.

[GOD-FR33]

I agree.....

"only his jealousy of pac made him finally step up"

I agree with this hence the reason Marquez juiced up at age 39 because he knew that's the only chance he had. His obession and hatred toward Manny is why I believe he would go to any lengths to win.

[Lords]

No but show me a fighter JMM beat, besides Pac, that would make it to round 5 vs 145lb Cotto.

Other than Floyd and manny, Jmm best wins were against 130-135 pound fighters.. How can you match them up against a 147 pound fighter?

[Bretty Poy32]

Other than Floyd and manny, Jmm best wins were against 130-135 pound fighters.. How can you match them up against a 147 pound fighter?

will cotto take a knee against jmm at 147 lb?

[HeroBando]

Other than Floyd and manny, Jmm best wins were against 130-135 pound fighters.. How can you match them up against a 147 pound fighter?

You can't, unless it's Pac. That's the point. He actually beat these big bad dudes. Marquez beat another midget, who beat the big guys.

[Lords]

You can't, unless it's Pac. That's the point. He actually beat these big bad dudes. Marquez beat another midget, who beat the big guys.

Who are these big bad dudes? Clottey? Margarita? Shane? Yea real bad.

[PunchesNbuncheS]

If we are talking about accomplishments then its PAC, but if we're talking about who was a greater boxer then it's Marquez. PAC accomplished a lot and that's not counting the bull**** stuff like Diaz at 135 or cotto at 145 or Margs at 150. But he still did a lot and he's an all time great. Amazing fighter but the catchweights and the steroid testing issue will always be a dark cloud over him and his legacy. Marquez is simply a better boxer and will be remembered as a better fighter especially because of the brutal nature of the KO.


PAC did more, Marquez is a greater fighter.

[elfag]

Marquez beat that ass 4 times.

Marquez is better.

[elfag]

will cotto take a knee against jmm at 147 lb?

Think you mean 145.

He wasnt the catchweight king for nothing.