One of the most ludicrous P4P list you've ever seen?

[Earl-Hickey]

i don't "like" tony thompson, but the fact remains that he might be the least talented american athletes at the top of his game, and he annihilated one of your best prospects.

and on sonning you, the domestic scene sons itself every saturday, when i see how little talent they've got. there are women on american streets who hit harder than that.

read the post again, because it's all the truth. unless you like the CW and HW divisions, or baby sized men, boxing in europe and asia is leagues below the united states.

Well Tony Thompson is your highest ranked heavyweight and he beanpoled the guy i'd put at like 4-5 of our heavyweights. So I don't see your point.

As to our "domestic scene", watch a lot of that do you?

[Doctor_Tenma]

In a sense I like P4P lists in that they truly expose those who do/ don't follow the sport in it's entirety. Broner, Canelo aren't in my top 10, nor are they close, and I've never cared to list my #11-15 or 20. Skill; versatility is a main criteria for me and while those two have it, they still have a lot of work to put in.

[Tmann400]

In a sense I like P4P lists in that they truly expose those who do/ don't follow the sport in it's entirety. Broner, Canelo aren't in my top 10, nor are they close, and I've never cared to list my #11-15 or 20. Skill; versatility is a main criteria for me and while those two have it, they still have a lot of work to put in.

Agreed. Canelo is just now finally facing a top 5 TRUE Jr. MW, and Ward has utterly destroyed the SMW division in it's entirety as well as steamrolled the LHW kingpin (Albeit in his weightclass) and yet you have Canelo on the list but not him? Regardless of whether Ward fought more then once last year or not, to me that's inexcusably incompetent.

[Doctor_Tenma]

No, don't disagree with Ward or JMM.

Broner is the problem as you say, also Floyd too high imo.

Broner is just in there because of his name imo. I mean really, that's it. Maybe in future he'll be there on merit but right now, I don't even know if he'stop 20 tbh.

TBH I am kind of surprised Danny Garcia isn't in there, he's the sort of guy The Ring loves.

You scared me there for a second.

[New England]

Well Tony Thompson is your highest ranked heavyweight and he beanpoled the guy i'd put at like 4-5 of our heavyweights. So I don't see your point.

As to our "domestic scene", watch a lot of that do you?

i generally catch the major cards, yes. i won't pretend to be the guy who can rattle off the limey top 10 in each division as if they matter.

[Weltschmerz]

That guy post on Boxingscene as GAR1680-Boxing
http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/member.php?u=192840


His criteria makes sense, but I would have Rios above Broner because he has a better resume.

The guy believes Deontay Wilder will bring the HW Crown back to America.

i generally catch the major cards, yes. i won't pretend to be the guy who can rattle off the limey top 10 in each division as if they matter.

No one matters other than Danny Williams, am I right?

amir khan's more like a falling stack of books than a robust tree.

Amir's got a chin like McCall. He just slips. A lot.

[cornholioda3rd]

he used to mention salita's name constantly, when it wasn't appropriate. there would be a discussion of top fighters at 140, and seckbach would bring salita's name up


the guy doesn't make much money from boxing, and he put himself up in a hotel and flew across the pond to see khan stop salita in one round. he was badly hurt with the first punch that landed.

That's... incredibly sad. But i'm still laughing my ass off. ******, predictable Elie.

[M Bison]

Not having Andre Ward in your P4P list is ****** very ******... but... Having Andre Ward rated as number 2 in your P4P list above the likes of ummm well I don't know??
Nonito Donaire, Wladimir Klitschko, Sergio Martinez and JMM
You're having a laugh if you think a guy who fought a super six tournament with absolutely no away fights in the whole entire tournament is worthy of such a privilege!
Roy Jones Jr claimed that P4P crown by moving up in weight and challenging the champion not calling out a smaller guy to move up weight for you or for a guy to come down weight and to fight you...
That isn't the act of a worthy #2 P4P fighter.