One of the most ludicrous P4P list you've ever seen?

[Tmann400]

I agree with some of the fighters on there. But it's ASTONISHING how you could have the likes of Alvarez and Broner on there and not Ward. Sure, Ward didn't fight twice in 2012, but given who he faced and how he won, as well as the dominant stretch of wins from November 2009-December 2011. It's just crazy to me. I like Broner, but No. 4?! Yet someone like Ward isn't even in your top 10? Ludicrous.

[JAB5239]

I agree with some of the fighters on there. But it's ASTONISHING how you could have the likes of Alvarez and Broner on there and not Ward. Sure, Ward didn't fight twice in 2012, but given who he faced and how he won, as well as the dominant stretch of wins from November 2009-December 2011. It's just crazy to me. I like Broner, but No. 4?! Yet someone like Ward isn't even in your top 10? Ludicrous.

Opinions and azzholes, everyone has them but some stink more than others. I agree 100% with you.

[thuggery]

Didn't Elie Seckbach at one point have Salita in his top 5 p4p?

[Earl-Hickey]

P4P lists are a load of **** generally anyway.

The Ring Magazines one is garbage, the criteria is as follows

1. American?
2. Fights on HBO?
3. Is he any good?

In that order

[Chiboxing123]

This dude is an idiot. He should never be allowed to talk about the sport again.

[ElBossHogg™]

any list with broner is not a credible list.

[PACnPBFsuck]

That guy post on Boxingscene as GAR1680-Boxing
http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/member.php?u=192840


His criteria makes sense, but I would have Rios above Broner because he has a better resume.

[LacedUp]

P4P lists are a load of **** generally anyway.

The Ring Magazines one is garbage, the criteria is as follows

1. American?
2. Fights on HBO?
3. Is he any good?

In that order

Took the words right out of my mouth.

[New England]

Didn't Elie Seckbach at one point have Salita in his top 5 p4p?

he used to mention salita's name constantly, when it wasn't appropriate. there would be a discussion of top fighters at 140, and seckbach would bring salita's name up


the guy doesn't make much money from boxing, and he put himself up in a hotel and flew across the pond to see khan stop salita in one round. he was badly hurt with the first punch that landed.

[thuggery]

he used to mention salita's name constantly, when it wasn't appropriate. there would be a discussion of top fighters at 140, and seckbach would bring salita's name up


the guy doesn't make much money from boxing, and he put himself up in a hotel and flew across the pond to see khan stop salita in one round.

Elie's a damn fool