This is Boxing...a Broke Nose... really !!!!

[vacon04]

You really over estimate your ability to understand. Now read it again then ask a sensible question. Or go to shut down on your computer or mobile device.

Then tell me exactly what do you think. I asked a very specific question which was "If boxing rules were changed so that every time a fighter gets a broken nose the fight is stopped, would you guys agree?", yet you answered some crap which had nothing to do with the question.

Maybe you overestimate your ability to understand questions.

[ThePunchingBag]

If they are intentional No. If they are accidental...yes! Serious?

So headbutts are completely legal blows as long as they're unintentional?

Really think about what you're saying here.

I'm giving you some time to not look like an idiot.

[boxingfan_123]

wasnt marquez fighting with a broken nose?

[-PBP-]

wasnt marquez fighting with a broken nose?

That was caused by a punch

[PAC-BOY]

So headbutts are completely legal blows as long as they're unintentional?

Really think about what you're saying here.

I'm giving you some time to not look like an idiot.

you will never make me look like an idiot...Accidents happen. There was never a warning or point taken. Accidents happen! You asked if it is legal. If you head butt someone on purpose...its an illegal blow/butt! If you accidentally :ANYWORD: hit or butt someone...you will be asked to watch it. And if you dont and keep doing the same thing over and over it becomes apparent that it is now intentional! Which becomes illegal! Headbutts are not used as Legal forms of hitting in Boxing....that is to be only used by the two hands of a fighter. But accidents to happen and a fighter will not be penalized for illegal blow or butt unless it is intentional.

[ßringer]

That was caused by a punch

What does how the broken nose happened have to do with anything?

A broken nose is never grounds for stopping a fight. Period.

[vacon04]

What does how the broken nose happened have to do with anything?

A broken nose is never grounds for stopping a fight. Period.

People here don't seem to understand that. A broken nose is a broken nose, it doesn't matter if it was caused by a punch or a headbutt.

[studentofthegam]

Then tell me exactly what do you think. I asked a very specific question which was "If boxing rules were changed so that every time a fighter gets a broken nose the fight is stopped, would you guys agree?", yet you answered some crap which had nothing to do with the question.

Maybe you overestimate your ability to understand questions.

Heres your answer. The answer is no. The rules are fine how they are because it makes sense to people with common sense. I just pray youre never on a rules commitee. sheeesh.

That was caused by a punch

These MF's are really remedial. Its getting embarrassing. His answer will probably be "But what if it wasnt a punch?"

[PAC-BOY]

What does how the broken nose happened have to do with anything?

A broken nose is never grounds for stopping a fight. Period.

Oh man....i keep reflecting back to Arthur Abraham getting his JAW broken in the 4th round and fighting on for 12 rounds!....

[vacon04]

Heres your answer. The answer is no. The rules are fine how they are because it makes sense to people with common sense. I just pray youre never on a rules commitee. sheeesh.

These MF's are really remedial. Its getting embarrassing. His answer will probably be "But what if it wasnt a punch?"

So then I got to agree with you this time, I don't understand what you're saying.

You agree with a stoppage because of a broken nose, yet you think that not every fighter who gets a broken nose should be stopped from fighting. Rules are rules, they shouldn't be different for every circumstance. If you think a broken nose is enough to stop a fight then that should be the case every time a fighter gets a broken nose, not just when you think is a good idea.

I guess that's the reason people like you don't make the rules.