Lets say Judah beats Garcia..and Mosley beats Paulie

[The Big Dunn]

Would you like to see the fight that never happened now????

assuming they both win, at 147 it wouldn't make sense because zab would have more lucrative fights at 140. I just don't see the reason for it.

[Rip Chudd]

No, I never want to see Mosley fight again and that includes this Malignaggi fight

[RL_GMA]

[THE REED]

Lets say both Mosley and Judah lose... which is really what's going to happen.

Still care to see it?

Sure, throw it on May 4th.

[-Kev-]

I wasn't going to pay for it in 2008, I'm damn sure not going to pay for it now.

Nobody was going to pay for it, it was HBO WCB.

[deejd]

Two different weight classes. Judah's stated that he's staying at '40. Also, he requested extra testing back in 2008 for Mosley; didn't get the green light, though...

[-Kev-]

It would feel wrong.

Na, it wouldn't. It feels wrong now, but boxing fans are very sensitive on a fight by fight basis. If Mosley looks good and wins, and Judah scores the upset, people would then change their feeling and say "Why not".

Who cared about Garcia vs Matthysse until Garcia knocked out Khan and Matthysse knocked out Soto? Nobody. Now the match up has a life of it's own, as if it's been in demand for years, when it was just born recently. Boxing fans are that sensitive.

[yuppie]

Na, it wouldn't. It feels wrong now, but boxing fans are very sensitive on a fight by fight basis. If Mosley looks good and wins, and Judah scores the upset, people would then change their feeling and say "Why not".

Who cared about Garcia vs Matthysse until Garcia knocked out Khan and Matthysse knocked out Soto? Nobody. Now the match up has a life of it's own, as if it's been in demand for years, when it was just born recently. Boxing fans are that sensitive.

But Garcia,Matthysse, Khan and Soto are all in (and there abouts) their prime. Mosley is a 41 year old who's last great fight was in 2009.
Im a fan of Paulie but i know as soon as he fights a legit fighter he will lose his belt.

[Hougigo]

They can dub it,
Aliens vs Mummies

[bojangles1987]

Na, it wouldn't. It feels wrong now, but boxing fans are very sensitive on a fight by fight basis. If Mosley looks good and wins, and Judah scores the upset, people would then change their feeling and say "Why not".

Who cared about Garcia vs Matthysse until Garcia knocked out Khan and Matthysse knocked out Soto? Nobody. Now the match up has a life of it's own, as if it's been in demand for years, when it was just born recently. Boxing fans are that sensitive.

It would feel wrong because Judah would have a chance, no matter what happens in their upcoming fights. If Zab Judah ever ended up with a win over ancient Shane Mosley, I'd feel sick to my stomach.