Originally posted by Someone88
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Did Vitali Klitschko "dominate" Lennox Lewis?
Collapse
-
Originally posted by IMDAZED View PostIf your argument for Vitali Klitschko forces you to ask what the definition of a tomato can is then I suggest you let this go.
If you say Vitali only fought cans and other HW greats were not or if you say Vitali fought more cans than other great HWs then I need to know what you mean with 'tomato can'. Isn't that reasonable?
Argument for Vitali can consist of many things but you can always say he fought 'tomato cans' so that's why I am asking.
You want to talk about accomplishments - well they are pretty numerical and factual - so I need a common ground here.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Simurgh View PostDude, is that the best you got?
If you say Vitali only fought cans and other HW greats were not or if you say Vitali fought more cans than other great HWs then I need to know what you mean with 'tomato can'. Isn't that reasonable?
Argument for Vitali can consist of many things but you can always say he fought 'tomato cans' so that's why I am asking.
You want to talk about accomplishments - well they are pretty numerical and factual - so I need a common ground here.
Comment
-
Originally posted by IMDAZED View PostI'm still waiting for you to tell me who Vitali beat. Then we can start comparing the quality of those wins to other opponents.
Is this satisfactory?
Full list you can find on wikipedia, so I don't know what you really askLast edited by Simurgh; 01-18-2013, 07:19 AM.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Someone88 View PostOk I saw a few lists. It seems harder now that I saw the list. Maybe ahead of Baer, Walcott, Charles. I'm more sure of Vitali being in the top 25.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Simurgh View PostVitali is easily better than all three of them. They can't even compete. They have more losses, far fewer championship fights and they fought overall weaker opposition.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Someone88 View PostIn ability I think Vitali is one of the best heavyweights in Boxing history. I'm not as sure with accomplishments, but you make good points so he could be in the top 20.
Comment
Comment