leonard over hagler or mayweathrer over martinez

[boxa_ali]

If mayweather was to fight martinez at middle weight and win.
Would that be considered a greater victory than leonard over Hagler.

[happyman]

i dont think so imo, though it'd be a huge feat.

and floyd isn't known to take these.

[Redd Foxx]

Leonard over Hagler is probably a bad example. Many do not consider it a great victory for the way it went down.

[boxa_ali]

So who is mayweather hagler that would cement his legacy and
Prove his self proclaimed greatness

[Redd Foxx]

So who is mayweather hagler that would cement his legacy and
Prove his self proclaimed greatness

Thing is, Leonard had Hearns, Duran, Hagler, etc, etc. He defeated many greats and lost to a few too. Floyd has no loses, but no great wins either. So, the legacy will be rooted in the 'O', not in the fights he took. And, I say that as someone who likes him.

[bojangles1987]

Leonard did not beat Hagler.

But since he does hold the victory, outside of knocking Martinez out I don't see how Floyd beating Martinez would be a better victory.

[IronDanHamza]

Leonard over Hagler.

Wouldn't matter if Mayweather knocked out Martinez in 1 round it still wouldn't be better than that.

[MJ223]

Leonard over Hagler.

Wouldn't matter if Mayweather knocked out Martinez in 1 round it still wouldn't be better than that.

What he said......

[RichCCFC]

no even though Leonard was far bigger than Floyd, Hagler even past his prime is the best middleweight ever

[boliodogs]

No, Martinez is no where near as good as Hagler.