Tougher fight for Mayweather : Canelo or Guerrero?

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Who gives Floyd the toughest fight? Simple question fellas.

[orriray59]

Canelo, by quite a distance.

[dan_cov]

Canelo, by quite a distance.

Based on? Just out of interest.

Can't see a flat footed guy with no jab giving Floyd any issues myself.

[puga]

guerrero . good inside fighter , good punch out put, good skills ..plus , he's a south paw..

[~AK49~]

Based on? Just out of interest.

Can't see a flat footed guy with no jab giving Floyd any issues myself.

and that applies to guerrero aswell?

My votes for canelo, mainly because of his power. While guerrero can put in some work, i dont see his punches being sharp enough, having enough power, etc to trouble mayweather. Mayweather is too skilled, and can deal with it easily enough imo.

While mayweather is more skilled than canelo aswell, canelo has the power to seriously hurt mayweather imo, especially/specifically his body shots. Id pick mayweather to beat both of them, but canelo is the more dangerous fight out of the two.

[Hatesrats]

Where is the "Both" option.
RG & Alvarez each bring their own set of problems for Floyd.

[AllEyesOpen]

Style-wise I give a slight edge to RG, but not for the same reason other people are giving it to him. I think Guerrero might be able to beat Mayweather with a stiff jab from the outside and outbox him, he has the size and style for it. I honestly think Mayweather is a much better fight on the inside then Berto and Guerrero.

Canelo in his own right has a decent chance, he throws some serious power shots, and if he's in actual serious condition to throw more then a handful of punches per round he might be a threat to Mayweather, but i give the edge to Guerrero.

[gmc_rfc_06]

Guerrero is better, Canelo is bigger.

Seing as I don't believe anyone is capable of outboxing Mayweather, that means I will say the guy with the huge size advantage has the better chance...even though he's not as good.

[GrandpaBernard]

and that applies to guerrero aswell?

My votes for canelo, mainly because of his power. While guerrero can put in some work, i dont see his punches being sharp enough, having enough power, etc to trouble mayweather. Mayweather is too skilled, and can deal with it easily enough imo.

While mayweather is more skilled than canelo aswell, canelo has the power to seriously hurt mayweather imo, especially/specifically his body shots. Id pick mayweather to beat both of them, but canelo is the more dangerous fight out of the two.

Guerrero has a jab

[sharpe]

I think Canelo is the tougher fight, he is very big and strong and has good power, whereas Guerrero has just moved up and doesn't pack the kind of punch that will worry mayweather.

They have similar experience but Guerrero has probably fought better competition, although I don't know why beating Berto lands you a fight with Mayweather. It sure didn't help Ortiz much