Comments Thread For: Closing 2012: BoxingScene Pound-for-Pound Update

[revs1227]

I AGREE WITH WARD AT 1

there absoiluley no way u can justify floyd at #1 not for a while
trout did a better job with cotto than he did and lopez beat ortiz cleaner lol

but yea
id just switch bradley and vilora and its a good list

[mathed]

That list is atrocious......no Wlad, no Bradley, no Guerrero and Ward #1?. This list is not Mathed approved

[revs1227]

The writer does have strange reasoning for putting Andre Ward as the number one. Mayweather is still p4p a harder hitter than Ward, has more accomplishments, and still has better defense than Ward. So I think Floyd is still number one. Ward is probably number 2, Marquez 3, Martinez 4, and Pacquiao 5.

harder hitter??? since when does tht matter ?
alotta people if not everyone on the list hits harder than floyd

floyd is great but his best days are well past
out with the old in with the new
wards RECENT PERFORMANCES TOTALLY ECLIPSE ANYTHING FLOYD HAS OFFERED SINCE RICKY HATTON DEFENSE 5 YEARS AGO

WARD IS THE BEST IN THE WORLD

ONLY FLOYD RIDERS CANT SEE THIS

[boxingfan76]

Great REAL list Ward ABSOLUTLEY deserves that number 1 slot just look at the guys hes beat, Mayweather is ranked too high becuase whos he beat to be considered number1? JMM was a good victory but who else?? nobody, his comp was always weak and opportunistic always ducked the meanest and top guys till this day,Ward has done the exact opposite Good list keeping it real ,,If Mayweather somehow CONVICINGLY beat Guerrerro And Canelo then maybe he can be a legit pnd for pnder ,given his recent performances i dont sdee him beating both Maybe 1 but not both, hes slipped alot. Manny should exit the list altogether because of the nature of that ko and 3 lousey performances in a row,it remains to be seen if hell even be competetive from here on out let alone pnd for pnd.

[bojangles1987]

That is an absolutely terrific p4p list. Can't complain about a single ranking.

[Motofan]

I never ever reply/post on here but this p4p list is just bull****. Im a BIG ward fan but come on we all know Mayweather is #1 on p4p hands down.

Gotta disagree with you man. Floyd of today is not the fighter he used to be. He gets hit more and is much more stationary. And I say this as someone who has full respect for Floyd's ability, but Ward is more unbeatable than a 35 year old Floyd. You could even argue that Nonito is more unbeatable at his weight than a 35 year old Mayweather is. Floyd needs to stop after these two fights or he risks losing. Hell, he risks losing these. Oh, and good list.

[crold1]

That list is atrocious......no Wlad, no Bradley, no Guerrero and Ward #1?. This list is not Mathed approved

Wlad is there.

[littlemac]

Good list, but Manny is still ranked much too high.

[daggum]

broner not on the list? what is wrong with you! did hbo/haymon forget to pay you off?

[crold1]

broner not on the list? what is wrong with you! did hbo/haymon forget to pay you off?

Yeah, no, they missed the Christmas bonus season. LOL