Comments Thread For: Closing 2012: BoxingScene Pound-for-Pound Update

[El Angel]

No way in hell should donair be higher then mares and Brian viloria shouldn't even be on the dam list

Donaire's win over Nishioka trumps Mares' win over Moreno IMO, just because Nishioka was #1 at SFW and Moreno was #1 also, but at BW. Still great win for Mares. Vilora's run lately has been very understated, his win over Marquez cinched a top 10 spot for him IMO.

[crold1]

I also think Froch is too high, but it's a good list overall. Danny Garcia is listed in the first 5 out, and also in the next 5 out though FYI.

Caught that. Should be Roman in the latter.

[ИATAS]

I used to point to The Ring as the official top 10 p4p, but they've become such a joke I'm going to use BoxingScene for now as my reference. Good job guys

[crold1]

please dont let it be crold please dont let it be crold.

dammit it, its Crold.

Yawn, another horrible list, cmon Crold1, you dont listen to criticism, just let someone else make these lists. You clearly cant separate being a fanboy for being a journalist. Learning how to deal with criticism is one of those things that separates the fine line of fanboy : journalist.

Your like the local version of Ronnie Nathanielsz, but maybe thats your goal

Yawn back.

[PACnPBFsuck]

crold, where did you have Pacquiao on your previous list?

[crold1]

crold, where did you have Pacquiao on your previous list?

Ward, Pac, May, JMM in the last list.

[PACnPBFsuck]

Ward, Pac, May, JMM in the last list.

I just wanted to see how far you had dropped him.

[wizard king]

Donaire's win over Nishioka trumps Mares' win over Moreno IMO, just because Nishioka was #1 at SFW and Moreno was #1 also, but at BW. Still great win for Mares. Vilora's run lately has been very understated, his win over Marquez cinched a top 10 spot for him IMO.

Ur nuts mares wins are a way more meaningful while donair wins are total bull crap with his best win being montel,and viloria is just laughable shouldn't be on thier Iam not even going to debate that one.

[SlimTim]

Rold, while I applaud you for not having the likes of Tim Bradley on your list, I must ask how in the hell is Ward number one? He cleaned out 168 but has taken no fights in which he was not favored. Yes, give him credit for stopping Dawson and decisioning Froch in boring fashion but he did go life and death with the always underrated Sakio Bika. For him to be considered in the top two he should have to prove himself against dangerous challenges higher in weight like Mayweather, Pacquiao, Marquez, Donaire, and even Martinez have all done. I can't take your list seriously until you move Ward back a bit.

[pugilistprophet1994]

Best list I have seen so far. Way better than The Rings ****ty list. Glad to see Mares, Froch, and Viloria make it on there. Also pleased to not see Broner on there. This is my new official list. No problem with Ward #1 could flip him or Mayweather, either way is good for me