Post your p4p top 10.

[RapidFire26]

1. Andre Ward
2. Floyd Mayweather
3. Juan Manuel Marquez
4. Nonito Donaire
5. Sergio Martinez
6. Wladimir Klitschko
7. Carl Froch
8. Manny Pacquiao
9. Tim Bradley
10. Vitali Klitschko (hard to fill 10 spot for me)

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

1. Mayweather Jr.

2. Ward

3. JMM

4. Martinez

5. Donaire

6. Wlad

7. Pacquiao

8. Froch

9. Mares

10. Bradley

[dan_cov]

Your list could be destroyed from top to bottom, yet you can only pick at my 10 guy. He just destroyed the to guy at 135 in his first fight moving up.

You got Guerrero a guy who went lie and death with bum ass Berto in the top ten.

The only place DeMarco is the top guy is in Bronerland.
Vazquez and Abril are the real top guys not DeMarco. The Ghost went up two divisions after an 18 month lay off and hammered the **** out of undefeated, top 10 Aydin and beat the much bigger Berto's ass from pillar to post despite being a good size underdog.

Broners resume is a fcuking joke & tbh your list isn't exactly much different from mine.

[Da Machine]

The only place DeMarco is the top guy is in Bronerland.
Vazquez and Abril are the real top guys not DeMarco. The Ghost went up two divisions after an 18 month lay off and hammered the **** out of undefeated, top 10 Aydin and beat the much bigger Berto's ass from pillar to post despite being a good size underdog.

Broners resume is a fcuking joke & tbh your list isn't exactly much different from mine.

I don't think Broner has some spectacular resume, but I don't consider Guerreros last two wins that impressive. I think Demarco was the better win, and I jut flat out see Broner as more talented.

I think I would rather have mares at 10. I will admit that.

May
Ward
Martinez
Marquez
Donaire
Wlad
Pac
Bradley
Froch
Mares

[toshmurph]

I always find it difficult to draw up these, and always second guess myself but here's mine.

1. Mayweather
2. Ward
3. Marquez
4. Martinez
5. Donaire
6. Pacquiao
7. W. Klitschko
8. Mares
9. Froch
10. Viloria

[teddycanyon]

1. Mayweather Jr.
2. Ward
3. Donaire
4. Marquez
5. Pacquiao
6. W. Klitschko
7. Martinez
8. Bradley
9. Mares
10. V. Klitschko (about to lose his spot to Froch if he doesn't fight soon)

[teddycanyon]

NSB is being being too harsh on Pac with some dropping him to #8 on the list, he fought a war with Marquez one of the best fighters on the planet and came up on the losing end of it. I still think he's ahead of Martinez who almost got KO'd by a fighter nowhere near the p4p list.

[Da Machine]

NSB is being being too harsh on Pac with some dropping him to #8 on the list, he fought a war with Marquez one of the best fighters on the planet and came up on the losing end of it. I still think he's ahead of Martinez who almost got KO'd by a fighter nowhere near the p4p list.

I think your reaching there, Martinez won 11 rds against a proven, massive MW. Chavez had easy wins over Rubio and Lee.

[yoz]

LOL at Tim Bradley.


No Donaire, seriously?

[RapidFire26]

NSB is being being too harsh on Pac with some dropping him to #8 on the list, he fought a war with Marquez one of the best fighters on the planet and came up on the losing end of it. I still think he's ahead of Martinez who almost got KO'd by a fighter nowhere near the p4p list.

It wasn't just that Pacquiao got knocked out. It was the manner he got knocked out in. He's obviously a great fighter, but I find it hard to keep him in the top 5 after that. He can obviously work himself back in very quickly though.

The fact is Sergio completely dominated Chavez for 11 rounds. Chavez was at least in the top 4 of the MW division (based on results against decent competition at the time) and #2 on many lists. This obviously was not due to skill, but mostly because of his size, which affords him greater durability and power. He outweighed Martinez by 15+ pounds on fight night, so it was still impressive in some ways. I'll agree Marquez is a much more skilled opponent, but we should keep in mind he was the same size as Pacquiao (maybe slightly smaller) and Manny got knocked down twice. The second time he got knocked out cold whereas Martinez got back up and kept on fighting.

I know he had a knockdown of his own against Marquez and was doing pretty good, but it is hard to keep someone in the top 5 after getting knocked out cold.