How would Marquez do against Pacquiao's opposition in the last 4 years?

[BennyST]

I decided to vote 4-3, even though it'd probably be more likely as 3-4. I'm feeling the love today.

[Capaedia]

Oscar @ 147 (2008)
Hatton @ 140 (2009)
Cotto @ 146 (2009)
Clottey @ 147 (2010)
Margarito @ 151 (2010)
Mosley @ 147 (2011)
Bradley @ 147 (2012)

Beats those versions of Oscar, Hatton and Mosley handily. UDs all around. A stoppage of Hatton (his chin wasn't ever the same after Mayweather) or Oscar (Oscar ****ed himself up big-time. Not Pacquiao's fault) not completely out of the question

Maybe beats Cotto and Clottey. Cotto's corner and team were in a shambles and he'd just been brutalized by Margarito, and Clottey would probably find some way to lose when faced with another Mexican Terminator.

Warquez.

He loses to Margarito. He would be giving away too much size to a pressure-fighter.

[IronDanHamza]

I actually think he'd win them all.

[Capaedia]

I actually think he'd win them all.

I wish I could agree, really, but he has nothing to discourage Margarito from throwing, nor does he have the strength to back him up and stop him.

Even that version was a biiig pressure fighter. Not good for a blown-up old man.

His style doesn't match up as well as Manny's did.

[The Big Dunn]

How would Marquez do against these guys?

Oscar @ 147 (2008)
Hatton @ 140 (2009)
Cotto @ 146 (2009)
Clottey @ 147 (2010)
Margarito @ 151 (2010)
Mosley @ 147 (2011)
Bradley @ 147 (2012)

at the time manny fought those fights, I don't know if JMM beats any of them. But I agree with New England and Larry-we tend to over reat on NSB some times and it doesn't matter if he loses to all or beats them. Only matters what he did on Saturday night.

[IronDanHamza]

I wish I could agree, really, but he has nothing to discourage Margarito from throwing, nor does he have the strength to back him up and stop him.

Even that version was a biiig pressure fighter. Not good for a blown-up old man.

His style doesn't match up as well as Manny's did.

I'm not sure.

I don't see that version of Margarito beating any top fighter, to be honest.

[RIZO24]

Who cares.. All that matters is what happened Saturday...

[Jordank]

How would a LW do against a bunch of WW? Thats you're question? Because Manny did get knocked out by a LW.

[gmc_rfc_06]

Current Marquez versus the version of those guys that fought Pac, I'll go 6-1.

Oscar was a skeleton, he'd have no chance. Hatton was done. Cotto is where I think the L would come, he could box with JMM and is just bigger (even though he wasn't at a weight which allowed him to be his best or with a good trainer). Clottey isn't active enough. Margarito was done. Mosley was a complete shell after the beating he took from Mayweather. Bradley....meh, routine win for JMM.

[MurkaMan]

How would Marquez do against these guys?

Oscar @ 147 (2008)
Hatton @ 140 (2009)
Cotto @ 146 (2009)
Clottey @ 147 (2010)
Margarito @ 151 (2010)
Mosley @ 147 (2011)
Bradley @ 147 (2012)

With the power, I think he can do the similar to them all, what Pac did! He can stop a shot mosley and cotto! I dont know if he throws enough punches to TKO Margarito, like Pac almost did.