Is there any Welterweight in history that could go through Oscar's resume undefeated?

[IronDanHamza]

I doubt anyone could go through Oscar's resume undefeated.

But you could say that about a long long list of people.

[onetwopunch]

You people act like Robinson is a god or some shit. I've seen some of his fights on video and dude has tons of flaws. Dude looked so great against people that had double digit losses. Just like Jones did fighting them cab drivers/cops. **** Robinson lost to Lamotta once who's a poor man's version of Chavez.

LaMotta is a poor mans version of Chavez?..You dont respect the sport for what it is..SRR, was the best fighter ever..there shouldnt even be an argument there..Your nationalistic pride is blurring your vision man..SRR would straight knock everyone one out on DLH's resume..were talking guys that would box 15rd fights..true killers.

[Ido]

Oscar had a shockingly tough resume, with most of the fighters he went against in their prime or still elite.
Mosley X2
Hopkins
Sturm
Trinidad
Ike
Floyd
Pacquaio
Vargas
Whitakker (although he was past it by than)
etc.

I'm thinking of a few.

Ray Robinson
Ray Leonard
Hearns
Duran
Wifred Benitez


The obviously problem is close to Prime Hopkins at 158-160. I don't see Wilfred, or even Ray Leonard having much of a chance against a 6'2 ATG fighter like Hopkins. I think the MW Version of Duran would have dropped against the Hopkins who fought Oscar and Tito as well.

Guys like Trinidad and Vargas were extremely dangerous as well as the Roided Up Mosley that Oscar went to war against twice.







ASSUME that you can just use the Prime Version of each Welterweight over and over again. Do you think anyone can go through that resume undefeated?

Assuming Ray Leonard is in his prime, and he has to jump weights to meet his adversaries. Yup, thats mah pick.

[IronDanHamza]

LaMotta is a poor mans version of Chavez?..You dont respect the sport for what it is..SRR, was the best fighter ever..there shouldnt even be an argument there..Your nationalistic pride is blurring your vision man..SRR would straight knock everyone one out on DLH's resume..were talking guys that would box 15rd fights..true killers.

Robinson has a shot at winning all those fights.

No way is he knocking out Hopkins though.

[Mr Randy Watson]

robinson, leonard, and hearns have the best chances

[Pin Galarga]

Recently as a welter I will say Cotto, if He wouldn't be assaulted with plasters, Mayweather still is, but its really about how long they fought at the weight. Sooner or later, someone's style will clash against anyone. No one is perfect.

[Mr. Fantastic]

LaMotta is a poor mans version of Chavez?..You dont respect the sport for what it is..SRR, was the best fighter ever..there shouldnt even be an argument there..Your nationalistic pride is blurring your vision man..SRR would straight knock everyone one out on DLH's resume..were talking guys that would box 15rd fights..true killers.

From all the fights I've seen he is.

@ I don't respect the sport for what it is. I'm just telling you what I saw. You don't have to agree. SRR is the best based on OPINION, some other people have other boxers that think they're better than Robinson.

Nationalistic pride? You obviously have no clue.

Just cause you can box 15+ rounds doesn't make you a killer. With the flaws I saw in Robinson, I don't think he can knock everyone of them out in DLH's resume.

[Ido]

Lets Make it more interesting. I am changing a few dates around.
Say the starting weight is 140, and the people on DLH list are in their prime.

140 - Chavez Sr.
140 - Manny Pacquiao
147 - Pernell Whitaker
147 - Ike Quartey
147 - Felix Trinidad
147 - Shane Mosley
154 - Fernando Vargas
154 - Ricardo Mayorga
154 - Floyd Mayweather Jr
160 - Felix Sturm
160 - Bernard Hopkins


Not a single soul, can clear this.

[onetwopunch]

From all the fights I've seen he is.

@ I don't respect the sport for what it is. I'm just telling you what I saw. You don't have to agree. SRR is the best based on OPINION, some other people have other boxers that think they're better than Robinson.

Nationalistic pride? You obviously have no clue.

Just cause you can box 15+ rounds doesn't make you a killer. With the flaws I saw in Robinson, I don't think he can knock everyone of them out in DLH's resume.

Flaws you saw in Robinson..thats great..monday morning quarterbacking..but lets look at the facts 173W 19Loss..6 draws..wow...its easy took look at it now and say wow..yeah he had flaws..but when your in the ring getting punched in the face its not the same..And yes Nationalistic pride.."chicano"..and your little pic there of DLH punching Tito in the face.

[-PBP-]

Lets Make it more interesting. I am changing a few dates around.
Say the starting weight is 140, and the people on DLH list are in their prime.

140 - Chavez Sr.
140 - Manny Pacquiao
147 - Pernell Whitaker
147 - Ike Quartey
147 - Felix Trinidad
147 - Shane Mosley
154 - Fernando Vargas
154 - Ricardo Mayorga
154 - Floyd Mayweather Jr
160 - Felix Sturm
160 - Bernard Hopkins


Not a single soul, can clear this.

Consider how many years it would take to clear that resume too. You have to find a guy who was still fighting and winning at the elite level well into his mid to late 30's.