Adalaide Byrd

[dan_cov]

Come on man 6 rounds a piece for Hopkins and Calzaghe? GTFO.

Hopkins scored a knockdown too...

[elgranluchadore]

i think she is a good judge too. she kinda sticks out for being a woman which reeks of incompetence (see julie lederman)

[Tuavale]

Adalaide Byrd seems to get a lot of stick over her scoring. Seen a lot of comments lately since she has been announced as judging Pac vs JMM 4

Personally I feel she is the best most unbiased judge in boxing and is a credit to the sport.

I am uncertain where the dislike has generated.

Okay she scored Trout v Cotto 119-109, I only gave Cotto 2 or 3 rounds myself and I am pretty sure those were swing-rounds that could of gone either way.

She scored Abril v Rios - 117-111 for Abril, that is great judging.

I've looked through most of her scoring and I genuinely can not see why people are against her judging.
Adalaide Byrd 114-113 (Hopkins over Calzaghe) is the only card I can find where I could maybe see people questioning it, again, this was a close fight!

I see she has been judging in a few controversial fights, but her scorecards are always **** on. So why the hate?

She is probably the best in the business. I hope she doesn't make me look a kn0b now and hand some ridiculous scorecard in

That is one judge I have faith in.

I think she votes with the brothas but since we don't have one here I don't know what she'll do. Not crazy about her myself. Think she's more than capable of a smelly scorecard.

[Jam Jars]

Trout outworked Cotto in every round. Cotto won no clear rounds and only had 2 or 3 close ones. Landing 3 punches at the end of the round doesn't make up for what Trout did for the majority of the round.

[Jam Jars]

Byrd was the judge for Pacquiao-Cotto/De La Hoya obviously easy fights to judge but she did give the widest cards on both occasions.

[-Jay-]

She's the one who scored it 119-110?
A little too wide.... she gets praise for the Abril fight though

No judge is going to get it right 100% of the time. I did think the scoring for Cotto/Trout was a little wide but I'm not going to go on a rampage over it.

[Motofan]

If the worst scorecard someone can find is Super Joe vs Bhop I think she will be fine.