Jose Luis Castillo VS Floyd Mayweather I, Who really won??

[jas]

Round 1: Mayweather
Round 2: Castillo
Round 3: Mayweather
Round 4: Mayweather
Round 5: Mayweather
Round 6: Castillo
Round 7: Castillo
Round 8: Castillo (point taken from Castillo for hitting on the break)
Round 9: Castillo
Round 10: Mayweather (point taken from Floyd for use of the elbow)
Round 11: Mayweather
Round 12: Mayweather

114-112 Mayweather

[johnm is...]

I showed the Castillo fight to a couple casual fans who are friends of mine a couple months ago; they think Castillo beat Floyd.

Whenever someone claims Floyd is truly undefeated; a quick YouTube search will show that it simply isn't true.

A lot of people feel that way. A lot of people feel opposite. But we're not going to re-write history.

[BOXEO _]

LOL,

[Caught Square]

I showed the Castillo fight to a couple casual fans who are friends of mine a couple months ago; they think Castillo beat Floyd.

Whenever someone claims Floyd is truly undefeated; a quick YouTube search will show that it simply isn't true.

Wow so some casual fans felt Castillo won, what does that prove?

[Beercules]

Wow so some casual fans felt Castillo won, what does that prove?

That if you show the Castillo fight to a casual fan they will most likely think Castillo won. That's what it proves.

Let's cut the BS. Floyd didn't win the first fight, admit it and move on.

Like John said; we can't rewrite history: but we can watch that fight again. Robberies happen in boxing, Castillo fell victim to that unfortunate situation.

[Beercules]

LOL,

[Caught Square]

That if you show the Castillo fight to a casual fan they will most likely think Castillo won. That's what it proves.

Let's cut the BS. Floyd didn't win the first fight, admit it and move on.

Like John said; we can't rewrite history: but we can watch that fight again. Robberies happen in boxing, Castillo fell victim to that unfortunate situation.

What was your scorecard for this fight?

[IMDAZED]

LOL,

True boxing fans understand that CompuBox means squat and is often erroneous.

[Kuyukut]

castillo clearly won that fight. i scored it 8 - 4 giving fraud jr the close rds.

btw same score i have for the 1st maidana fight.

[jas]

castillo clearly won that fight. i scored it 8 - 4 giving fraud jr the close rds.

btw same score i have for the 1st maidana fight.

I agree with you on the chino fight

116-112 maidana.

Second one was closer for me

115-113 maidana giving fraud jr benefit of doubt for ring generalship