Where do you put Guerrero on the P4P list?

[..David..]

He would be a top 10 if Berto wasnt suspended.

IMO Guerrero deseves credit but the Berto he fought last night was just awful.

Props to Guerrero it was his fight all night

[mathed]

A few years ago I made a post: Martinez, Bradley, and Guerrero would be top 5 p4p......looks like my prophecy is almost fulfilled.

[Barry Halls]

Outside of top10. That's all i care to rate.

[Bermuda]

lol just stop posting here

viloria imo is more deserving of being on the top ten p4p list than bradley. he stopped segura who was ranked top ten p4p...and he just beat the #1 guy in his division in a fight of the year candidate and as a result unified the wbo and wba belts...bradley on the other hand only fought once this year and it was a gift decision against pac and before that he fought a past it joel casamayor..his win against devon alexander was a nice win even though the win wasn't very spectacular...and bradley looked sloppy as hell.

[MikeRo1972]

With all due respect to The Ghost and his recent impressive win. Lets not get crazy now, exactly who has he beaten to be given P4P consideration? Berto? Aydin? Kataidis? Casamayor? Lets pump our breaks a bit. These are all punching bags. Not saying he won't get there. I hope he does, I used to live in the Bay so I've been following him for a minute but lets take it easy with P4P talk. He needs to beat fighters like Floyd, JMM, Manny, and to a lesser extent Bradley, Alexander, etc.
If Broner isn't on that list yet then Guerrero sure as hell has no business on it.

Howeva! I'd love to see Guerrero take on Abregu then on to one of the big boys.

[M Bison]

1 Floyd Mayweather
2 Sergio Martinez
3 Manny Pacquiao
4 Wladimir Klitschko
5 Juan Manuel Marquez
6 Nonito Donaire
7 Andre Ward
8 Vitali Klitschko
9 Danny Garcia
10 Robert Guerrero

Yeah 10th I'd say.

[Fighting_Pride]

not even part of the top 20

[-PBP-]

Not top 10 is all I know.

But he easily top 5 at 147.

[The Hammer]

1 Floyd Mayweather
2 Sergio Martinez
3 Manny Pacquiao
4 Wladimir Klitschko
5 Juan Manuel Marquez
6 Nonito Donaire
7 Andre Ward
8 Vitali Klitschko
9 Danny Garcia
10 Robert Guerrero

Yeah 10th I'd say.

Good list, except Floyd Mayweather is too inactive to be ranked #1.

[shade darkar]

i think he is a top 10 p4p fighter. bottom half tho. similar sort of ranking as bradley id say.