If Donaire fights and beat Rigondeaux, is he the GOAT?

[kiaba360]

Credit yes but the only way he goes over Ward or Martinez (IMO) is if the other two have poor showings/bad fights.

I think cleaning out the division (beating Rigo and the winner of Moreno/Mares) would solidify his P4P ranking. I would put him at #3 without hesitation.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

The hell is wrong with you people.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Obviously I don't literally mean THE greatest fighter of all time...

That is literally what "The GOAT" means

[DARKSEID]

I'd rather see him fight Mares tbh. Rigo hasn't proven anything and I'm tired of donaire fighting people who are 100% defense, which rigo already is, it doesn't matter who against who.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[DARKSEID]

mares is the tournament winner and is a very tough fighter. It's the best and most entertaining fight donaire can be in right now.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[SkillspayBills]

He would get major major props from me. Rigo has the skill, speed, ability, and Ring IQ to beat Donaire. So if he takes that bout and comes out on top clearly, he deserves a ton of credit.

[MeanestNiceGuy]

Nope. I can't stand Donaire, but I know for a fact that he KO's Rigondeaux.

I say that because of the way Marroquin had him on ***** street in the 2nd and 9th round.

Both of those punches were left hooks, and Donaire throws his with speed and conviction. Not to mention those right hands that were catching Rigo most of the night.

Will he be the greatest of all time? Nope. Rigondeaux would have to be a highly regarded fighter at this time, and that's not the case.

Im sure he wants to get this fight out of the way though.

[Bermuda]

it would be a nice win..probably his 4th or 5th best win behind darchinyan, montiel, nishioka and narvaez. i think a win vs the mares vs moreno winner will be alot better.

[-Johannes-]

Rigo should give Donaire his Olympic medal if Donaire beats him. It should be in the Contract as an incentive for Donaire!

This would be kind of funny...

[Leonf96]

Honestly a win over anselmo moreno would impress me more