who's the fighter of the year so far?..

[crold1]

yah i think donaire has just accomplished more this year than the rest. arce will be a nice action packed fight to close off the year but doesn't do much in term of legacy for donaire.

Legacy is to be determined at the end of a career. If he fights four times in one year, that's great. All this 'every fight must weigh to legacy' crap is just that.

Crap.

I pay more attention when guys fight once-twice in a year. He just beat #1 and a top five in class in succession. I don't like the Arce fight because Arce hasn't a prayer.

[TX_BOXNG]

Garcia, Donaire, Martinez

i think Donaire will have another significant win later this year n will solidify his fighter of the year argument

[Bermuda]

Legacy is to be determined at the end of a career. If he fights four times in one year, that's great. All this 'every fight must weigh to legacy' crap is just that.

Crap.

I pay more attention when guys fight once-twice in a year. He just beat #1 and a top five in class in succession. I don't like the Arce fight because Arce hasn't a prayer.

that's true...i'm also worried about his left hand. i heard it was bloody again. hopefully if he does fight in december it heals properly. not sure it would be a good thing to keep aggravating the wound though.

[Phenom]

wins over Mathebula and Vazquez jr don't get you the fighter of the year not to mention Donaire looked like **** in those fights

for me its Carl Froch if he wins next month or Bradley

[puga]

wins over Mathebula and Vazquez jr don't get you the fighter of the year not to mention Donaire looked like **** in those fights

for me its Carl Froch if he wins next month or Bradley

carl froch has one win this year..and bradley has no chnce at all with that gift decision

[Canelo Phresh]

Martinez or Donaire. Hopefully they give it to Marquez after he gets ripped again this december.

[IronDanHamza]

Donaire probably.

After he knocks out Arce he'll definitely get it.

[crold1]

Donaire probably.

After he knocks out Arce he'll definitely get it.

When was the last time a guy went four times in one year at this level?

[fundicao]

Martinez , matthysse and garcia in that order

[-PBP-]

Sergio Martinez or Donaire.

Danny Garcia had the opportunity to take it by fighting a top guy on October 20 but chose the Morales rematch.